← Back to ASE Concepts & Practices Series
Purpose of This Paper
Throughout this series, I have argued that personal and social agency are one process expressed at two levels. Most of the attention, however, has been given to the student. This paper turns to the school. If a school is a conditioned process with its own orientation, as the first paper suggested, then it is reasonable to ask how a school thinks, intends, and acts, and how those institutional processes shape the conditions from which every student\'s choices arise. The purpose of this paper is to describe institutional volition from the perspective of Advocating Student-within-Environment (ASE) theory, to show how the volitional cycles of students and schools are coupled, and to describe the school counselor\'s role in helping a school observe and revise its own orientation.
Agency Beyond the Individual
The idea that groups and institutions have agency is not new. Bandura (2000) distinguished personal agency from proxy agency, in which people rely on others to act on their behalf, and from collective agency, which rests on people\'s shared beliefs in their capacity to produce results together. Early formulations of ASE theory drew on these distinctions, describing counseling work at the student level, the school level, and the level of proxy relationships between them. ASE theory has since moved toward a non-dual account in which these are not three separate agencies but expressions of one relational process at different levels.
Organizational scholars have offered complementary accounts. Douglas (1986) argued that institutions classify, remember, and frame on behalf of their members, shaping what those members find it natural to think. Hutchins (1995) showed that complex cognitive work is often distributed across people and the tools they share, so that the thinking of a group cannot be located in any one mind. Weick (1995) described organizations as engaged in ongoing sensemaking, in which members collectively construct accounts of what is happening and act upon those accounts. Each of these suggests that a school is more than a container in which students and adults act. It is a participant in what happens.
The Institutional Volitional Cycle
In a related manuscript, I describe thinking, intending, and acting as phases of a single volitional cycle for persons. The same cycle can be traced at the institutional level, as summarized in Table 1.
Table 1
Phases of Institutional Volition in Schools
----------- ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Phase How a school carries it out Examples Thinking Through the categories, data systems, forms, and meeting structures that determine what is noticed and how it is classified A referral form; an early warning dashboard; the agenda of a student support team; the labels used for groups of students Intending Through policies, plans, schedules, and stated priorities that arrange conditions in advance A discipline matrix; a master schedule; an attendance policy; a school improvement plan Acting Through the responses that adults make in the moment, often guided by habit How a teacher responds to a late arrival; how an office handles a referral; how a family is greeted at the front desk Observing Through review and reflection on outcomes, when such review occurs Data meetings; climate surveys; listening sessions; after-action reviews of incidents ----------- ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Each phase is a site of institutional orientation. What a school\'s forms ask about determines what its adults think about. What its policies prioritize determines what conditions it arranges in advance. How its adults habitually respond determines what students encounter in the moment. And whether and how a school observes its own outcomes determines whether its orientation can change.
Thinking
A school thinks through its categories. When a referral form asks only which rule was broken, adults learn to think about student behavior in terms of rules. When an early warning system flags attendance, grades, and behavior, adults learn to notice those three things and may overlook others (e.g., connectedness, sleep, family transitions). These tools are useful, and they are also orientations that have settled into structure. They make some thoughts easy and others remote.
Intending
A school intends through its policies and plans. A master schedule is an intention about what learning is for and who belongs where; an attendance policy is an intention about what absence means. Like personal intentions, institutional intentions work by arranging conditions in advance, so that when a situation arrives, a response is already near. Implementation intentions in persons link a future situation to a chosen response (Gollwitzer, 1999), and a discipline matrix does something very similar for an institution.
Acting
A school acts through its adults, and much institutional action is habitual. Under pressure, institutions, like persons, tend to fall back on their most practiced responses. A school that has long responded to disruption by removing students will tend to do so under stress even if its stated priorities have changed. This is one reason that policy change often fails to change practice; the policy changes the institution\'s stated intention without changing the conditions under which its adults act.
Observing
A school observes when it reviews its outcomes and asks what they mean. Argyris and Schön (1978) distinguished single-loop learning, in which an organization corrects its actions to better meet existing goals, from double-loop learning, in which it questions the goals and assumptions themselves. In ASE terms, single-loop learning adjusts conditions within an existing orientation, whereas double-loop learning makes the orientation itself available for change. A school that reviews suspension data and asks how to reduce suspensions is engaged in single-loop learning; a school that asks what it believes suspension is for, and whether that belief is serving its students, is engaged in double-loop learning.
Coupled Cycles
The volitional cycles of students and schools are coupled (see Figure 1). A school distributes conditions to students through what it thinks, intends, and acts upon; students return meaning to the school through their responses, which the school either observes or does not. Each cycle supplies conditions for the other.
Figure 1
Coupled Volitional Cycles of Student and School
{width="6.25in" height="3.65625in"}
Note. The school\'s thinking, intending, and acting distribute conditions that students inherit. Students\' responses return meaning to the school, which the school may or may not observe.
The coupling has several implications. First, it explains why student-level change is often short-lived when the school\'s cycle is unchanged. A student may form a new intention, but if the school continues to distribute the same conditions, the student\'s new response will be met by the same institutional response, and the old pattern will reassert itself. Second, it explains why institutional change must reach the level of action, where students actually encounter it. Third, it suggests that students\' responses are a form of institutional feedback. A pattern of student disengagement is, among other things, the school\'s own orientation returning to it.
The School Counselor and Institutional Orientation
School counselors occupy a distinctive position in relation to institutional volition. They participate in the school\'s thinking (e.g., data teams, student support teams), its intending (e.g., program planning, policy committees), and its acting (e.g., direct services, crisis response), and they are often among the few professionals in a building whose role includes attending to the experience of the whole school. ASE theory asks counselors to use this position to help the school observe its own orientation.
Helping the School Think Differently
Counselors can propose changes to the categories through which a school thinks. Adding a question about what a student may have needed to a referral form, including indicators of connectedness alongside indicators of risk, or beginning team meetings by naming strengths are each small changes in institutional thinking. These changes alter what adults find it natural to notice.
Helping the School Intend Differently
Counselors can participate in policy and planning with attention to the conditions that policies distribute. An ASE-informed review of an attendance policy, for example, would ask not only whether the policy is clear and consistently enforced but what conditions it creates for students who are late for reasons outside of their control.
Helping the School Act Differently
Because institutional action is largely habitual, changes in practice require rehearsal and support. Consultation that cultivates teachers\' regulation and relational orientation has been associated with reductions in teacher stress and improvements in teacher-student relationships (Molina et al., 2022), which suggests that it changes the conditions under which adults act. Counselors can also help schools build shared if-then plans for predictable difficult moments, so that a new institutional response is near when the moment arrives.
Helping the School Observe
Perhaps the most important contribution counselors can make is to help schools engage in double-loop learning. This includes bringing student voice into data review, disaggregating outcomes to make patterns visible, and asking, in planning meetings, what the school believes a policy or practice is for. Dialogical evaluation, described in the sixth paper, is the ASE approach to institutional observation.
Cautions
Institutions Are Not Persons
Describing institutions as thinking, intending, and acting is useful, although it carries a risk of reification. A school does not have a mind apart from its members, its tools, and its histories. ASE theory uses this language to describe distributed processes, not to suggest that a school is an agent that stands apart from the people in it. Institutional orientation changes when the people who carry it, and the tools through which they think, change.
Institutional Responsibility Is Real
The coupling of cycles does not reduce the responsibility of the school. If a school distributes conditions that make some choices far more available to some students than to others, that is the school\'s part in what follows, as the eighth paper argued. Institutional volition is a description of how schools participate in students\' lives, and it brings with it a corresponding accountability.
Conclusion
Schools think through their categories and forms, intend through their policies and plans, act through the habitual responses of their adults, and observe, when they do, through review and reflection. These institutional processes are coupled to the volitional cycles of students, distributing the conditions that students inherit and receiving, in students\' responses, the meaning of the school\'s own orientation. ASE theory asks school counselors to help schools observe and revise that orientation, so that the conditions a school distributes are positioned toward liberation and thriving for all of its students.
References
Argyris, C., & Schön, D. A. (1978). Organizational learning: A theory of action perspective. Addison-Wesley.
Bandura, A. (2000). Exercise of human agency through collective efficacy. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 9(3), 75--78. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-8721.00064
Douglas, M. (1986). How institutions think. Syracuse University Press.
Gollwitzer, P. M. (1999). Implementation intentions: Strong effects of simple plans. American Psychologist, 54(7), 493--503. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.54.7.493
Hutchins, E. (1995). Cognition in the wild. MIT Press.
Molina, C. E., Lemberger-Truelove, M. E., & Zieher, A. K. (2022). School counselor consultation effects on teachers\' mindfulness, stress, and relationships. Professional School Counseling, 26(1a), 1--9. https://doi.org/10.1177/2156759X221086749
Weick, K. E. (1995). Sensemaking in organizations. Sage.