← Back to ASE Concepts & Practices Series
Purpose of This Guide
Paper 9 described how schools think through their categories and forms, intend through their policies and plans, act through the habitual responses of their adults, and observe, when they do, through review and reflection. It argued that the volitional cycles of schools and students are coupled, and that school counselors are well positioned to help schools observe and revise their own orientation. This guide offers four practices for doing so: the Artifact Audit, the Purpose Dialogue, Student Voice in Data Review, and Shared Adult If-Then Plans.
The Idea in Lived Experience
Adults who work in schools rarely experience their school as something that thinks or intends. They experience forms to fill out, policies to follow, meetings to attend, and routines that were in place before they arrived. Yet each of these carries a reading of what students are and what school is for. A tardy slip that asks only for the time of arrival, and not the reason, reflects an orientation in which the reason does not matter. A data dashboard that flags risk but not connection reflects an orientation in which risk is what needs to be noticed.
In lived experience, institutional orientation is most visible to the people who are on the receiving end of it, and least visible to the people who carry it. Students can often say exactly how a school reads them; adults often cannot say how they read students, as the reading is built into the tools they use. Helping a school observe itself, then, begins with making its tools and habits visible.
Practice 1: The Artifact Audit
The Artifact Audit examines the documents and tools through which a school thinks. A counselor, ideally with a small team that includes teachers, an administrator, and students, gathers several artifacts (e.g., referral forms, attendance letters, behavior matrices, intake forms, data dashboards, the student handbook) and asks of each one four questions.
> 1\. What does this artifact ask about, and what does it not ask about? > > 2\. What does it make easy for adults to think, and what does it make remote? > > 3\. What reading of students does it carry? > > 4\. What small revision would widen what adults notice?
Table 1 provides examples of artifacts, the readings they may carry, and possible revisions.
Table 1
Examples From an Artifact Audit
------------------------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Artifact Reading it may carry Possible revision Discipline referral form listing rule violations only Behavior is a matter of rule-breaking Add: \"What might the student have needed in that moment?\" and \"What was happening before?\" Attendance letter to families citing legal consequences Absence is a matter of compliance Open with concern and an invitation: \"We\'ve missed your child and want to understand what is getting in the way.\" Early warning dashboard flagging attendance, behavior, and grades Risk is what needs noticing Add an indicator of connectedness (e.g., whether the student has a trusted adult) Student support team agenda beginning with concerns Students are first their problems Begin with strengths and conditions that help, then concerns Handbook section titled \"Consequences\" The school\'s role is to respond to misbehavior Retitle and reorganize around \"Repair and Support,\" with consequences described within it ------------------------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table 2
Artifact Audit Worksheet
-------------- --------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------ ----------------------- Artifact What it asks about / does not ask about What it makes easy to think / remote Reading of students it carries Proposed revision
-------------- --------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------ -----------------------
Practice 2: The Purpose Dialogue
The Purpose Dialogue is a brief protocol for double-loop learning, in which a school questions the goals and assumptions behind a policy and not only its implementation (Argyris & Schön, 1978). It can be used in a leadership team meeting, a faculty meeting, or a policy committee.
> 1\. Name the policy or practice (e.g., \"Students who are tardy three times receive a detention\"). > > 2\. Ask what the policy is for. Collect several answers; staff members often hold different understandings of the same policy. > > 3\. Ask what conditions the policy creates for students, including students for whom it was not designed (e.g., students who are tardy because they take younger siblings to school). > > 4\. Ask whether the policy is producing what it is for, using available data and student voice. > > 5\. Decide whether to keep the policy, revise its implementation, or revise its purpose.
The Purpose Dialogue often reveals that a policy was designed for one purpose and is serving another, or that staff disagree about its purpose without having discussed it. Making these differences visible is itself a form of institutional observation.
Practice 3: Student Voice in Data Review
Students\' responses to school conditions are a form of institutional feedback, as Paper 9 argued, although schools often observe these responses only as numbers. Inviting students into data review allows the school to receive the meaning of its own orientation more directly. A counselor might share disaggregated data on attendance, discipline, or course enrollment with a small group of students and ask what they think the data mean, what conditions might explain them, and what they would change. Students\' interpretations are often different from adults\', and they frequently identify conditions that adults have overlooked.
Practice 4: Shared Adult If-Then Plans
Because much institutional action is habitual, new policies often fail to change practice. Shared adult if-then plans help a school make a new response near at hand for predictable moments. A grade-level team, for example, might agree that \"if a student arrives late and visibly upset, we will greet them, offer a quiet minute, and ask if they want to check in with the counselor before asking about the tardy.\" Rehearsing such plans together, in calm conditions, makes them more likely to be used under pressure (Gollwitzer, 1999).
A Lived-Experience Illustration
At an elementary school, here called Maple Street, the counselor noticed that most discipline referrals described student behavior in a single word (e.g., \"disrespect,\" \"defiance\"), and that the referral form provided a checklist of such words. With the principal\'s support, the counselor led an Artifact Audit with a team of three teachers, the assistant principal, and two fifth-grade students. The students pointed out that the form \"only says what we did wrong, not why.\" The team revised the form to include two new questions, \"What was happening before?\" and \"What might the student have needed?\", and replaced the checklist of single words with a brief space for an observable description.
The team then held a Purpose Dialogue about the referral process itself and discovered that teachers held different understandings of its purpose; some saw it as a way to get help, others as a way to document, and others as a consequence. The school clarified that referrals were primarily for getting help and created a separate process for documentation. Over the next semester, the counselor observed that referrals were more often followed by support than by consequence, and that teachers\' descriptions of students on the revised form were noticeably more curious. This illustration is fictional.
Practicing in One\'s Own Life
Counselors can apply the Artifact Audit to their own programs. Intake forms, needs assessments, program descriptions, and newsletters to families each carry an orientation. A counselor who audits their own artifacts may find, for example, that their referral form for counseling services lists only problems, or that their family newsletter describes counseling as something for students who are struggling. Revising one\'s own artifacts is a form of practicing what one asks of the school.
Adaptations and Cautions
- Begin with small, low-stakes artifacts. An audit of the student handbook may be too large a first step; an audit of one form is more manageable and can build trust.
- Involve the people who use the artifacts. Revisions imposed from outside are unlikely to change what adults think.
- When involving students in data review, protect confidentiality and avoid sharing data in ways that could identify individual students or groups.
- Institutional change can be slow, and counselors should be prepared for resistance. Framing audits and dialogues as shared inquiry, and not as critique, tends to reduce defensiveness.
References
Argyris, C., & Schön, D. A. (1978). Organizational learning: A theory of action perspective. Addison-Wesley.
Douglas, M. (1986). How institutions think. Syracuse University Press.
Gollwitzer, P. M. (1999). Implementation intentions: Strong effects of simple plans. American Psychologist, 54(7), 493--503. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.54.7.493