← Back to ASE Concepts & Practices Series
Purpose of This Guide
Paper 8 argued that ASE theory distributes responsibility without dissolving it, so that a student remains accountable for her behavior while the adults, routines, and institutions around her are accountable as well. This guide translates that position into practice. It describes how to facilitate the ASE repair sequence (i.e., Steady, Map, Own, Repair, Arrange) after a conflict or harm, how adults can practice owning their part, and how a school can review patterns of incidents so that institutional responsibility becomes visible.
The Idea in Lived Experience
In most schools, the question asked after an incident is \"Who did it, and what happens to them?\" The question is reasonable and incomplete. In lived experience, incidents rarely have one author. A fight at recess may involve two students, a game with unclear rules, a crowded corner of the playground, a supervising adult who was attending to something else, and a long-standing tension that began in the classroom. Each participant played a part.
Living with distributed responsibility does not mean that no one is held to account. It means that more people are. The student who threw the first punch is accountable for that, and the school is accountable for the unsupervised corner. This can feel unfamiliar, especially for adults who have been trained to see responsibility as belonging to students. It can also feel freeing, as it replaces the search for a culprit with a shared question about what each person can do.
Practice 1: The Repair Conversation
The repair conversation follows the five steps of the ASE repair sequence (see Figure 1). It can be held with one student and one adult, with two or more students, or, for more serious incidents, as a larger circle including family members. The counselor typically facilitates.
Figure 1
The ASE Repair Sequence
{width="6.25in" height="2.2916666666666665in"}
Note. Each step should be completed before moving to the next. Owning and repairing are shaded to indicate that they involve every participant, including adults.
Steady
Do not begin a repair conversation while anyone is still activated. Co-regulate first, which may take minutes or may mean waiting until the next day. Adults should check their own regulation as well. A facilitator who is angry or hurried will not be able to hold the conversation.
Map
Ask each participant to describe what happened, one at a time, without interruption. Then widen the view by asking what was happening before the incident, what each person was carrying into the moment, and what the setting was like. The facilitator can use the Kaleidoscope Map from Practice Guide 2 to make the conditions visible.
Own
Invite each participant to name their part. Begin with the person most likely to model it well, which is often an adult. A teacher who says, \"I raised my voice before I found out what was going on, and I think that made it worse,\" makes it far easier for a student to say, \"I pushed him first.\" Owning is offered by each participant, as opposed to a confession extracted under pressure, and the facilitator should not move forward until each participant has had the opportunity to offer it.
Repair
Ask the person who was harmed what they need, and ask each participant what they will do to make things right. Repairs should be concrete and chosen by the participants where possible (e.g., an apology in the participant\'s own words, replacing something that was damaged, helping with a task, agreeing to a new way of handling a disagreement).
Arrange
Ask what will be different in the conditions so that this is less likely to happen again. This step distinguishes ASE repair from approaches that address the incident and leave the conditions in place. Arrangements might include a supervision change, a plan for a difficult moment, a seating change, or matching if-then plans between a student and teacher.
Table 1 offers facilitation prompts for each step.
Table 1
Facilitation Prompts for the Repair Conversation
---------- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- Step Prompts for students Prompts for adults Steady \"Let\'s take a minute before we talk. What does your body need right now?\" \"Before we begin, how are you doing? Are you ready to listen?\" Map \"What happened, from your side? What was going on for you before it happened?\" \"What was the setting like? What was happening in the class before this?\" Own \"What part did you play in what happened?\" \"Is there anything you did, or didn\'t do, that contributed?\" Repair \"What do you think would help make this right? What do you need from the others?\" \"What can you do to help repair this?\" Arrange \"What could be different next time? What would help you choose differently?\" \"What could we change in the room, the schedule, or the routine?\" ---------- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Practice 2: Adults Owning Their Part
The step that adults find most difficult is owning their part, partly because school cultures often treat adult acknowledgment of error as a loss of authority. In ASE practice, the opposite is true. An adult who owns their part demonstrates that accountability is something people in a community practice together, which strengthens the adult\'s authority with students instead of weakening it.
Counselors can support adults in this practice through consultation. One approach is to rehearse owning statements in advance, which can be brief and specific (e.g., \"I didn\'t give a warning before I took the phone, and I could have\"). Another is for the counselor to model owning their own part in team settings (e.g., \"I didn\'t follow up with the family when I said I would\"). Over time, adult owning becomes part of the school\'s culture, and students begin to expect it.
Practice 3: Pattern Review
Institutional responsibility is difficult to see one incident at a time. A Pattern Review examines discipline and incident data for patterns that point to conditions, such as when incidents occur, where they occur, which adults are involved, and which groups of students are most often affected. A pattern of incidents concentrated in one hallway at one time of day points to a condition in that hallway. A pattern in which one group of students receives exclusionary consequences at higher rates for similar behaviors points to a condition in the school\'s orientation (Skiba et al., 2014).
A counselor might lead a Pattern Review with a school leadership team each quarter, asking four questions: Where and when are incidents concentrated? Who is most affected? What conditions might be contributing? What will we arrange? The final question makes the review a form of institutional repair.
Table 2
Repair Plan Worksheet
----------------- ------------------------------------ --------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------ ------------------- Participant Their part, in their own words What they will do to repair What will be arranged so it is less likely Check-in date
----------------- ------------------------------------ --------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------ -------------------
A Lived-Experience Illustration
During an eighth-grade science class, a student, here called Kofi, threw a textbook across the room after his teacher, Mr. Harris, took his phone. No one was hurt, although a classmate was frightened. Kofi was sent to the office, and the next day the counselor facilitated a repair conversation with Kofi, Mr. Harris, and, at her request, the classmate.
During the Map step, it emerged that Kofi had been texting his mother, who was in the hospital, and that Mr. Harris had taken the phone mid-message without warning. In the Own step, Mr. Harris said, \"I took it without asking what was going on, and I did it in front of everyone.\" Kofi then said, \"I threw the book, and it almost hit her. That wasn\'t okay.\" The classmate said she needed to know it would not happen again. In the Repair step, Kofi apologized to her directly, and Mr. Harris apologized to Kofi. In the Arrange step, they agreed that when Kofi needed to check his phone for family reasons, he would signal and step into the hall, and Mr. Harris would allow it without comment. The counselor also took the incident to the school\'s leadership team, which revised its phone policy to include a process for students with urgent family situations. This illustration is fictional.
Practicing in One\'s Own Life
The repair sequence is useful far beyond school discipline. Counselors can use it after conflicts with colleagues, in their own families, and in their own relationships. Practicing it in one\'s own life, especially the Own step, makes a counselor more credible when asking students and adults to do the same. It also reveals how difficult owning one\'s part can be, which is useful information about what students are being asked to do.
Adaptations and Cautions
- With young children, keep the conversation short and concrete, and use pictures or role-play for the Repair and Arrange steps.
- Repair conversations are not appropriate when there is a significant power imbalance that cannot be addressed in the room, as in cases of bullying, harassment, or abuse. In such cases, follow school protocols, prioritize the safety of the person harmed, and do not require face-to-face repair.
- Repair does not replace required reporting or legal obligations.
- Do not use the Own step to pressure a harmed student into accepting blame for what was done to them. Owning applies to one\'s actual part, not to a share of every incident.
References
Gregory, A., Clawson, K., Davis, A., & Gerewitz, J. (2016). The promise of restorative practices to transform teacher-student relationships and achieve equity in school discipline. Journal of Educational and Psychological Consultation, 26(4), 325--353. https://doi.org/10.1080/10474412.2014.929950
Skiba, R. J., Chung, C.-G., Trachok, M., Baker, T. L., Sheya, A., & Hughes, R. L. (2014). Parsing disciplinary disproportionality: Contributions of infraction, student, and school characteristics to out-of-school suspension and expulsion. American Educational Research Journal, 51(4), 640--670. https://doi.org/10.3102/0002831214541670
Zehr, H. (2002). The little book of restorative justice. Good Books.