← Back to ASE Concepts & Practices Series
Purpose of This Paper
Any account of agency that emphasizes prior conditions will be asked about responsibility. If a student\'s behavior emerges from a complex total of conditions, many of which she did not choose, in what sense is she responsible for it? And if she is not wholly responsible, who else is? These questions are not abstract in schools. They are asked, implicitly, every time a student is sent to the office, every time a parent is called, and every time a team decides whether a behavior warrants support, consequence, or both.
The purpose of this paper is to describe how Advocating Student-within-Environment (ASE) theory understands responsibility. I contend that ASE theory distributes responsibility without dissolving it. Because the student is a condition in the arising of her own behavior, she remains accountable for it; because she is not its only condition, the adults, routines, and institutions around her are accountable as well. The paper then describes a practice of repair consistent with this view and considers its implications for school discipline.
Two Common Errors
Schools tend to err in one of two directions when they think about responsibility. The first error is individualizing. Here the student is treated as the sole origin of her behavior, such that responsibility is entirely hers and the conditions around her are, at most, excuses. This position fits the autonomous agent model critiqued in the first paper, and it leads easily to exclusionary discipline. Research has consistently documented that exclusionary practices such as suspension are applied disproportionately to students of color and students with disabilities, and that these disparities are not explained by differences in behavior alone (Skiba et al., 2014). An individualizing view of responsibility makes such patterns difficult to see, as each case is considered one student at a time.
The second error is dissolving. Here, recognizing the conditions behind a behavior leads to the conclusion that no one is responsible, because everyone was conditioned. This error is rarer in policy but common in conversation, and it can be just as harmful. A student who is told, in effect, that her behavior is not really hers is deprived of the authorship that ASE theory treats as the ground of commitment. Peers who were harmed by the behavior are deprived of acknowledgment. The adults and institutions involved are also let off, since if no one is responsible, no one need change.
ASE theory holds a third position, in that responsibility is real and distributed.
Responsibility as a Practice of Relationship
Much of the philosophical debate about responsibility concerns whether a person could have done otherwise, which is a version of the free will problem addressed in the first paper. P. F. Strawson (1962) offered an influential way around this debate. He argued that responsibility is grounded less in metaphysics than in the reactive attitudes (e.g., resentment, gratitude, indignation, forgiveness) through which people hold one another to account within ongoing relationships. To hold someone responsible, on this view, is to treat them as a participant in a shared life whose actions matter to others.
This view is congenial to ASE theory for two reasons. First, it locates responsibility in relationship, which is consistent with the non-dual understanding of the self. Second, it treats responsibility as something people do together, which opens the possibility of doing it well or poorly. A school that holds students accountable through relationship and repair is practicing responsibility differently from a school that holds them accountable through exclusion, even when both take a behavior seriously.
Young (2011) adds a forward-looking dimension. In her social connection model, responsibility for structural injustice falls on all those whose actions contribute to the processes that produce it, and it is discharged by acting together to change those processes and not only by assigning blame for past harms. ASE theory borrows this emphasis. Responsibility in schools looks backward, to what happened and who was harmed, and also forward, to what each participant will do so that it is less likely to happen again.
Distributed Responsibility
Figure 1 illustrates how ASE theory understands responsibility as distributed across the complex total of conditions from which a behavior emerges.
Figure 1
Distributed Responsibility Across the Complex Total of Conditions
{width="6.25in" height="4.4375in"}
Note. The student remains accountable for her behavior. Relationships, routines, policies, and broader social conditions are also conditions of that behavior, and responsibility is held at each level.
The figure should not be read as a set of concentric excuses, as though responsibility diminished at the center. Accountability is held at every ring. A student who hurts a peer is accountable for the harm. A teacher whose classroom routines leave long unstructured periods is accountable for those routines. A school whose discipline policy removes students from instruction at disproportionate rates is accountable for that policy, and the broader community is accountable for the resources it does or does not provide its schools. These responsibilities do not compete. Recognizing the school\'s part does not reduce the student\'s part, and recognizing the student\'s part does not reduce the school\'s.
This position follows from the argument of the first paper. If the complex total of conditions cannot be divided cleanly into the student\'s portion and the setting\'s portion, then responsibility cannot be assigned wholly to either. What can be done is to ask, of each participant, what part they played and what part they can play now.
A Practice of Repair
ASE theory describes repair as a sequence that holds responsibility and conditions together (see Figure 2). The sequence is consistent with restorative practices, which emphasize repairing harm and restoring relationships over punishment (Zehr, 2002), and which have shown promise for improving teacher-student relationships and reducing disparities in discipline (Gregory et al., 2016). ASE theory adds an emphasis on conditions and orientation, so that repair attends to what produced the harm and not only to the harm itself.
Figure 2
The ASE Repair Sequence
{width="6.25in" height="2.2916666666666665in"}
Note. The sequence moves from co-regulation, to mapping conditions, to each participant naming their part, to repair, and to rearranging conditions so that the harm is less likely to recur.
Steady
Repair is unlikely while anyone involved is in a state of threat. As described in earlier papers, stress shifts behavior toward habit, and a student or adult who is still activated will tend to repeat the very responses that produced the harm. The first step is therefore co-regulation, for the student and also for the adults involved.
Map
The second step is to map the conditions that gathered around the incident. What happened before? What was the student carrying into the moment? What was the classroom like? What did each participant think was happening? This step draws on the conceptualization practice described in the second paper, and it is done with the student and not about her.
Own
The third step is for each participant to name their part. The student names what she did and how it affected others. Adults also name their part, where they had one (e.g., \"I raised my voice before I asked what was going on\"). This step is the center of distributed responsibility, and it is often the step that adults find most difficult. When adults name their part, students learn that accountability is something people in a community practice together and not something imposed by one side.
Repair
The fourth step addresses the harm. What does the person who was harmed need? What will each participant do to make things right? Repair is concrete and, where possible, chosen by the participants, as outcomes that are authored are more likely to be experienced as one\'s own (Caspar et al., 2016).
Arrange
The final step looks forward. What will be different in the conditions so that this is less likely to happen again? This might include a change in seating, a plan for a difficult transition, a matching set of intentions between student and teacher, or a change in a schoolwide routine. This step distinguishes ASE repair from approaches that address the incident and leave the conditions intact.
Language for Distributed Responsibility
The language that counselors and educators use can individualize, dissolve, or distribute responsibility. Table 1 offers contrasting examples.
Table 1
Language That Individualizes, Dissolves, or Distributes Responsibility
---------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Individualizing Dissolving Distributing (ASE) \"He chose to hit him, so he\'s suspended.\" \"He couldn\'t help it, given everything at home.\" \"He hit him, and that hurt someone. A lot was going on for him this morning. What does he need to make it right, and what do we need to change about recess?\" \"She just doesn\'t care about school.\" \"It\'s not her fault; the system failed her.\" \"She\'s been missing class, and it\'s costing her. Let\'s figure out what\'s pulling her away and what each of us can do.\" \"These kids have no self-control.\" \"These kids have been through too much to expect anything.\" \"Afternoons are hard for this group. What can they practice, and what can we arrange?\" ---------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------- -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Implications for School Discipline
ASE theory does not oppose consequences. Some behaviors require that a student be removed from a setting for the safety of others, and natural and logical consequences can be part of learning. What ASE theory opposes is discipline that individualizes responsibility while leaving conditions unexamined, and discipline that removes students from the very relationships and instruction through which they might compose a different pattern.
Several implications follow for ASE-informed school counselors. First, counselors can advocate for discipline processes that include a mapping of conditions as a matter of routine, such as referral forms that ask what the student may have needed. Second, counselors can review discipline data at the level of patterns (e.g., time of day, setting, adult, group of students) and not only at the level of individual students, which makes institutional responsibility visible. Third, counselors can model owning one\'s part in their own practice, which signals to colleagues that adult accountability is part of the culture. Fourth, counselors can help ensure that repair includes the student\'s voice, so that what follows an incident adds to the student\'s sense of authorship instead of eroding it.
Conclusion
ASE theory holds that responsibility is real and distributed. A student is accountable for her behavior because she is a condition of it; the adults, routines, policies, and communities around her are accountable because they are conditions of it as well. This position avoids both individualizing and dissolving responsibility, and it suggests a practice of repair that steadies, maps, owns, repairs, and arranges. Responsibility in this sense is something a school community practices together, looking back to what happened and forward to what each participant will do so that the next moment inherits better conditions.
References
Caspar, E. A., Christensen, J. F., Cleeremans, A., & Haggard, P. (2016). Coercion changes the sense of agency in the human brain. Current Biology, 26(5), 585--592. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2015.12.067
Gregory, A., Clawson, K., Davis, A., & Gerewitz, J. (2016). The promise of restorative practices to transform teacher-student relationships and achieve equity in school discipline. Journal of Educational and Psychological Consultation, 26(4), 325--353. https://doi.org/10.1080/10474412.2014.929950
Skiba, R. J., Chung, C.-G., Trachok, M., Baker, T. L., Sheya, A., & Hughes, R. L. (2014). Parsing disciplinary disproportionality: Contributions of infraction, student, and school characteristics to out-of-school suspension and expulsion. American Educational Research Journal, 51(4), 640--670. https://doi.org/10.3102/0002831214541670
Strawson, P. F. (1962). Freedom and resentment. Proceedings of the British Academy, 48, 1--25.
Young, I. M. (2011). Responsibility for justice. Oxford University Press.
Zehr, H. (2002). The little book of restorative justice. Good Books.