← Back to ASE Concepts & Practices Series
Purpose of This Paper
The first six papers in this series argued that Advocating Student-within-Environment (ASE) theory holds a non-dual view of self and environment, and that agency is a function of the orientation to experience and the establishment of the complex total of the prior conditions of experience. A reasonable reader might press the argument further. If there is no fixed self, what remains of personal identity? A student answers to her name, remembers last year, and anticipates graduation; she is recognizably the same person on Monday that she was on Friday. Something persists, and ASE theory owes an account of it.
The purpose of this paper is to offer that account. I contend that personal identity in ASE theory is best understood as a pattern of conditioned and conditioning processes that holds together over time, and that memory, both explicit and implicit, is the primary medium through which that pattern is carried forward. Memory is a prior condition of experience; it is also, each time it is recalled, an act of orientation that revises what is carried. Behavior, in turn, both expresses and composes the identity from which it appears to flow. The paper closes with implications for school counseling practice and with cautions about working with memory in schools.
What Remains of Identity
Two answers to the question of identity are familiar, and ASE theory accepts neither. The first holds that beneath changing experience there is an unchanging core, a true self that persists and that experience merely decorates. This view is incompatible with the non-dual commitments described in the first paper. The second holds that because there is no unchanging core, there is no identity at all, only a succession of disconnected moments. This view is incompatible with the phenomenological reality that ASE theory insists upon, and it would leave a counselor with no one to work with.
Buddhist philosophy, upon which ASE theory draws, has long navigated between these two positions. The early tradition rejected both eternalism (i.e., a permanent self) and annihilationism (i.e., no continuity whatsoever) in favor of a middle account in which the person is a continuum, or stream, of causally connected events (Siderits, 2007). A stream has no fixed substance, yet it is identifiable, it has a recognizable character, and what happens upstream shapes what happens downstream. The identity of the stream consists in the pattern of its flow.
Western philosophy offers a complementary distinction. Ricoeur (1992) separated two meanings of identity, sameness (idem), or the persistence of the same characteristics over time, and selfhood (ipse), or the kind of constancy displayed when a person keeps a promise even though she has changed. Ricoeur argued that narrative mediates between the two; a person\'s identity is the story through which changing characteristics are held together as one life. For ASE theory, this distinction is useful. Sameness is largely a matter of constitution, the characteristics a person has inherited and accumulated. Selfhood is closer to what ASE theory calls composition, the self that persons put together, over time and with others, from what was set up.
What remains of identity, then, is a pattern that is real without being fixed. It includes characteristic ways of perceiving, habitual responses, embodied dispositions, relational styles, values, and the stories a person tells and is told about who they are. Others can recognize this pattern, and the person experiences it as \"me.\" Identity, then, is a way that experience is organized, as opposed to a possession standing behind experience, and it changes as the conditions and orientations that sustain it change.
Memory as Prior Condition
If identity is a pattern carried over time, memory is the principal means of carrying it. ASE theory treats memory as a prior condition of experience, and it is useful to distinguish three forms that memory takes in the lives of students and schools (see Figure 1).
Figure 1
Memory as Prior Condition and as Orientation in ASE Theory
{width="6.25in" height="3.9895833333333335in"}
Note. Explicit, implicit, and social memory enter present experience as prior conditions. The meaning made of present experience, through observation and dialogue, revises what is remembered.
Explicit Memory
Explicit memory includes memories that can be consciously recalled and described, such as episodes from one\'s life and facts one knows (Squire, 2004). For identity, the most important form is autobiographical memory, the remembered episodes a person organizes into an account of who they are. Research on autobiographical memory suggests that it is constructed and not simply retrieved; what is recalled is shaped by a person\'s current goals and self-understanding, and in turn shapes them (Conway & Pleydell-Pearce, 2000). A student who believes she is \"bad at school\" recalls the failures that confirm the belief more readily than the successes that would complicate it.
Implicit Memory
Implicit memory includes what has been learned without being consciously recalled, such as skills, habits, conditioned emotional responses, and expectations about how others will behave (Squire, 2004). Much of what ASE theory calls constitution is carried in this form. A nervous system that braces when an adult raises her voice is remembering, although the student may recall nothing in particular. Attachment research describes a related phenomenon; early relationships leave behind internal working models, or implicit expectations about whether others will be available and whether one is worth caring for, that shape later relationships (Bowlby, 1982). Implicit memory is often the most powerful governor of a student\'s present experience precisely because it does not announce itself as memory. It arrives as perception.
Social Memory
Memory is not only carried by persons. Halbwachs (1992) argued that individual remembering is always framed by the groups to which a person belongs, and that families, communities, and institutions maintain memories of their own. Schools remember in this sense. A cumulative file, a discipline record, a reputation passed from one grade-level team to the next, and a family\'s history with a school are each forms of social memory. These memories function as governors of a student\'s experience, as they shape how adults read the student before the student has done anything at all.
Memory as Orientation
Memory is a prior condition, yet ASE theory also understands remembering as an act of orientation. Each time a memory is recalled, it is reconstructed in the present, with present meaning and present purposes. Research on memory reconsolidation suggests that recalled memories enter a temporarily changeable state before they are stored again, which means that recall is an occasion on which memory can be revised (Nader et al., 2000). Although the clinical implications of this research are still debated, it is consistent with a long tradition in counseling that treats the retelling of experience as a site of change.
This places memory squarely within the ASE account of conditions and orientation. Memory is condition that was once orientation; the meaning made of an earlier experience settled into what is now carried. Remembering is orientation acting upon condition; the meaning made now, in recalling, revises what will be carried forward. Stated otherwise, memory is where the mutual constitution of conditions and orientation can be most directly observed in a single life.
Behavior Within a Non-Fixed Identity
If identity is a pattern carried by memory, then behavior is the visible side of that pattern. Behavior expresses identity, as a student\'s habitual responses are shaped by what she remembers explicitly and implicitly. Behavior also composes identity, as what a student does today becomes part of what she, and others, will remember tomorrow. A student who, for the first time, asks for help instead of shutting down has done more than perform a single act; she has added a memory to the pattern, and the pattern has changed, however slightly.
Ricoeur\'s (1992) notion of selfhood as keeping one\'s word is relevant here. Commitment, which the fifth paper in this series described as the movement from openness to chosen reconstruction, is the point at which a student acts from a composed identity and not only from an inherited one. When a student makes a commitment and keeps it, she is not expressing a fixed self; she is composing a self that is constant in the way that matters for agency. This is one reason ASE theory places such weight on observing and naming new behavior. A behavior that is noticed and named is more likely to be remembered, and a behavior that is remembered is more likely to become part of the pattern.
Implications for School Counseling Practice
Table 1 summarizes how each form of memory functions as a governor and how ASE-informed school counselors might work with it.
Table 1
Forms of Memory as Governors of Experience and Corresponding ASE Practices
------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Form of memory How it functions as a governor ASE-informed practice Explicit (autobiographical) Organizes episodes into an account of who one is; recalls what confirms the current account Curious inquiry into exceptions; helping students author fuller accounts that include overlooked episodes Implicit (habit, bodily readiness, relational expectation) Arrives as perception; shapes responses before deliberate thought Co-regulation and repeated new relational experiences that build different expectations; noticing bodily cues without judgment Social (records, reputations, family and institutional histories) Shapes how adults read a student before the student acts Consultation about how students are introduced and discussed; attention to records and transitions; offering adults new episodes to remember ------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Working With Explicit Memory
Because autobiographical memory is constructed, the stories students tell about themselves can be enlarged. Narrative approaches to counseling describe this as attending to unique outcomes, the episodes that do not fit the dominant story and that, when recalled and elaborated, make room for a different account (White & Epston, 1990). In ASE practice, this is a form of expansion. A counselor might ask a student who describes himself as someone who \"always gives up\" to recall a time he kept going when something was hard, and then to consider what conditions were present in that time. The aim here is to restore to the student the episodes his current account leaves out, so that he can compose a self from a fuller record, as opposed to replacing one story with a more flattering one.
Working With Implicit Memory
Implicit memory is rarely changed by insight alone, as it was not learned through insight. It changes through new experience, repeated under conditions safe enough for the new experience to register. This is one of the most important reasons that co-regulation sits at the center of the 5Cs. A student whose implicit memory expects adults to respond with anger learns something different only by being met, repeatedly, by adults who respond with steadiness. Counselors can also help students notice implicit memory as it arises (e.g., \"Your shoulders went up when I mentioned the test. What do you notice?\"), which brings a governor that arrives as perception into the range of observation.
Working With Social Memory
School counselors are often positioned to influence how schools remember students. Transitions between grades and schools, student support team meetings, and the informal conversations in which adults pass along impressions are each moments when social memory is formed and transmitted. An ASE-informed school counselor might encourage teams to introduce a student by naming conditions and strengths in addition to concerns, or might ask whether an old discipline record still describes the student who is now in the room. Counselors can also help create new episodes for adults to remember, such as inviting a teacher to witness a student\'s contribution in a setting where the student is at her best.
Cautions
Memory Is Not to Be Corrected
The constructed nature of memory does not mean that students\' memories are inaccurate or that counselors should revise them. A student\'s memory of being excluded, harmed, or dismissed is a veritable part of her experience, and treating it as a construction to be reframed would repeat the harm. The ASE position is that memory can be enlarged and re-oriented through the student\'s own observation and authorship, not overwritten by the counselor.
Trauma Requires Care
School counselors encounter students whose memories include trauma. ASE theory does not recommend that school counselors elicit detailed recollection of traumatic events, which can be destabilizing without appropriate clinical structure and support. The emphasis in schools is on establishing present conditions of safety and co-regulation, attending to implicit memory as it shows up in the body and in relationships, and referring to community-based clinical services when more specialized treatment is warranted (Zyromski et al., 2022).
Institutions Must Remember Responsibly
Social memory can harm. Records and reputations can follow students long after they describe them, and the burden of such memories falls unevenly across groups of students. ASE theory treats the responsible management of institutional memory as a matter of fairness and belonging, and as part of the counselor\'s advocacy role.
Conclusion
ASE theory does not deny personal identity; it describes identity as a pattern that is real without being fixed, carried forward by memory and composed through behavior. Memory is a prior condition, as explicit, implicit, and social memory each shape present experience. Remembering is also an act of orientation, as each recall revises what is carried. This places memory at the meeting point of conditions and orientation, and it gives school counselors several avenues for practice, including enlarging the stories students tell, offering repeated new experiences that build different implicit expectations, and helping schools remember their students well. What persists of a student, from this perspective, is not a fixed core waiting to be discovered, but a composition that the student, together with the people and institutions around her, continues to put together.
References
Bowlby, J. (1982). Attachment and loss: Vol. 1. Attachment (2nd ed.). Basic Books. (Original work published 1969)
Conway, M. A., & Pleydell-Pearce, C. W. (2000). The construction of autobiographical memories in the self-memory system. Psychological Review, 107(2), 261--288. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.107.2.261
Halbwachs, M. (1992). On collective memory (L. A. Coser, Ed. & Trans.). University of Chicago Press.
Nader, K., Schafe, G. E., & LeDoux, J. E. (2000). Fear memories require protein synthesis in the amygdala for reconsolidation after retrieval. Nature, 406(6797), 722--726. https://doi.org/10.1038/35021052
Ricoeur, P. (1992). Oneself as another (K. Blamey, Trans.). University of Chicago Press.
Siderits, M. (2007). Buddhism as philosophy: An introduction. Hackett.
Squire, L. R. (2004). Memory systems of the brain: A brief history and current perspective. Neurobiology of Learning and Memory, 82(3), 171--177. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nlm.2004.06.005
White, M., & Epston, D. (1990). Narrative means to therapeutic ends. Norton.
Zyromski, B., Wolfe, T. E., Choi, J., Shrewsbury, S., & Hamilton, M. (2022). Applying an Advocating Student-Environment lens to foster protective factors: School counselors\' role in buffering ACEs. Journal of Child and Adolescent Counseling, 8(1), 1--15. https://doi.org/10.1080/23727810.2021.2021052