Practice Guide 7 · Companion to Paper 7

Remembering Well

Exceptions Lifeline + New Episodes + Fresh Introduction

Matthew E. Lemberger-Truelove — Department of Educational Psychology, Neag School of Education, University of Connecticut

Read companion Paper 7 →

← Back to ASE Concepts & Practices Series

Purpose of This Guide

Paper 7 described personal identity in ASE theory as a pattern that is real without being fixed, carried forward by explicit, implicit, and social memory and composed through behavior. It argued that remembering is an act of orientation, as each recall revises what is carried. This guide offers three practices that correspond to the three forms of memory: the Exceptions Lifeline, for explicit memory; New Episodes, for implicit memory; and the Fresh Introduction, for the social memory that schools hold about students.

The Idea in Lived Experience

Every student arrives at school carrying a history, and much of it is not visible. Some of it is in the stories the student tells (\"I\'ve always been bad at math\"). Some is in the body, as a readiness to flinch, to withdraw, or to argue before anything has happened. And some is held by others, in a cumulative file, a reputation in the teachers\' lounge, or a family\'s memory of how the school treated an older sibling.

In lived experience, these memories often feel like facts about who a student is. ASE theory treats them as conditions that can be enlarged and re-oriented. In practice, this involves helping students and schools remember more fully (without overwriting what happened), adding episodes that the dominant story leaves out, and creating new experiences that, repeated over time, build different expectations.

Practice 1: The Exceptions Lifeline

The Exceptions Lifeline is a way of enlarging the explicit, autobiographical memory a student draws on when describing who they are. It draws on narrative counseling\'s attention to unique outcomes, or episodes that do not fit the dominant story (White & Epston, 1990).

> 1\. The student names the story they tell about themselves in a particular area (e.g., \"I give up when things get hard\"). > > 2\. Together, the student and counselor draw a simple timeline covering the student\'s life or a relevant period (e.g., the last three school years). > > 3\. The student marks episodes that fit the story. The counselor does not argue with these. > > 4\. The counselor asks about exceptions, episodes, even small ones, when the story did not hold (e.g., \"Was there ever a time you kept going when it was hard?\"). Each exception is marked on the timeline. > > 5\. For each exception, the student and counselor explore what conditions were present (e.g., who was there, what the task was, how the student felt that day). > > 6\. The student considers what the full timeline suggests about who they are and what conditions help them.

The Exceptions Lifeline often reveals that exceptions cluster around particular conditions, such as a particular adult, a particular kind of task, or a particular time of day. This links the student\'s identity to arrangeable conditions and provides material for the Mirror Plan described in Practice Guide 6.

Table 1

Exceptions Lifeline Worksheet

--------------------------------- ------------------- ------------------------------------- ---------------------------------- ----------------------------- When (grade, month, or age) What happened Fits the story or an exception? What conditions were present What this says about me

--------------------------------- ------------------- ------------------------------------- ---------------------------------- -----------------------------

Practice 2: New Episodes

Implicit memory, such as a learned expectation that adults will respond with anger or that mistakes lead to humiliation, is rarely changed by talking about it. It changes through new experiences, repeated under conditions safe enough to register. New Episodes is a practice in which adults deliberately and repeatedly provide the experience that a student\'s implicit memory does not expect.

> 1\. Identify the implicit expectation, usually by observing the student\'s responses (e.g., a student who flinches or argues when corrected may expect correction to come with anger). > > 2\. Identify the moment in which the expectation is most often activated (e.g., when the teacher approaches the student\'s desk). > > 3\. Agree on a new response that adults will provide, consistently, in that moment (e.g., the teacher approaches slowly, crouches to eye level, and begins with something the student has done well). > > 4\. Repeat the new response many times. A single positive experience is easily dismissed as an exception; many repeated experiences begin to change the expectation. > > 5\. When the student\'s response begins to change, notice and name it together (see Practice Guide 4).

Counselors can also help students notice implicit memory as it arises, which brings it into the range of observation. Brief prompts such as \"Your shoulders went up just now. What do you notice?\" help students recognize that their body is remembering, which is the beginning of choosing how to respond.

Practice 3: The Fresh Introduction

Schools hold social memories of students, and these memories shape how adults read students before the students have done anything. The Fresh Introduction is a protocol for the moments when social memory is formed and transmitted, such as transitions between grades, new staff assignments, and student support team meetings.

A Fresh Introduction describes a student in four parts, in this order: (a) something the student cares about or does well, (b) conditions that tend to help the student, (c) conditions that tend to make things harder, and (d) a current goal, in the student\'s words if possible. Concerns are included under (c) and are framed as conditions instead of traits. Table 1 contrasts a typical introduction with a Fresh Introduction.

Table 2

A Typical Introduction and a Fresh Introduction of the Same Student

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Typical introduction Fresh Introduction \"This is DeShawn. He was suspended twice last year and has a behavior plan. Watch him in the hallway.\" \"DeShawn is a gifted artist and is great with younger kids. He does best when adults greet him by name and when he knows what\'s coming next. Hallway transitions and unexpected schedule changes have been hard for him; he was suspended twice last year after hallway conflicts. His goal this year, in his words, is to \'stay in class and finish my portfolio.\'\" ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Fresh Introduction does not hide concerns or records, which would be neither honest nor safe. It reorders what is remembered, so that the first thing an adult learns about a student is not the worst thing, and it frames difficulty as a matter of conditions that the adult can help arrange.

A Lived-Experience Illustration

A sixth-grade student, here called Lena, told her counselor that she was \"the bad kid\" and had been \"since kindergarten.\" Her cumulative file included several behavior notes from early grades, and two of her current teachers had heard about her from colleagues before the school year began. The counselor worked on all three forms of memory. With Lena, the counselor completed an Exceptions Lifeline, which revealed that Lena\'s \"good years\" (her phrase) had been second and fourth grade, both with teachers who, as Lena put it, \"talked to me like a normal person.\" With Lena\'s teachers, the counselor arranged New Episodes, agreeing that redirections would be given privately and calmly and that each teacher would find one thing to acknowledge each day. At the sixth-grade team\'s student support meeting, the counselor offered a Fresh Introduction of Lena that began with her love of animals and her helpfulness in the science lab.

By the spring, Lena still had difficult days, although she no longer described herself as \"the bad kid.\" When asked what had changed, she said, \"I don\'t know. It\'s like people here don\'t already know me.\" The counselor understood this to mean that the school\'s social memory of Lena had been loosened enough for a different Lena to be remembered. This illustration is fictional.

Practicing in One\'s Own Life

Counselors carry memories of their own that shape their practice, including stories about themselves as professionals (\"I\'m not good with angry parents\"), implicit responses formed in their own histories, and the social memory their school holds about the counseling role. An Exceptions Lifeline for one\'s own professional story can be illuminating. So can noticing which students one remembers by their difficulties and which by their strengths, as the counselor\'s own memory is part of the school\'s social memory.

Adaptations and Cautions

References

Halbwachs, M. (1992). On collective memory (L. A. Coser, Ed. & Trans.). University of Chicago Press.

Squire, L. R. (2004). Memory systems of the brain: A brief history and current perspective. Neurobiology of Learning and Memory, 82(3), 171--177. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nlm.2004.06.005

White, M., & Epston, D. (1990). Narrative means to therapeutic ends. Norton.