← Back to ASE Concepts & Practices Series
Purpose of This Paper
Each of the preceding papers has described the student and the school as conditioned and conditioning processes. The final paper in this series applies the same analysis to the school counselor. If the counselor\'s curiosity is the first condition under which a student\'s curiosity might appear, as the fourth paper suggested, then the counselor\'s own culture, constitution, circumstance, and orientation are part of the complex total from which students\' experiences arise. The counselor is not an observer standing outside of the student-within-environment, but a participant within it.
The purpose of this paper is to describe the counselor as a condition in ASE theory. I address the non-dual educator-counselor identity that ASE theory proposes for school counselors, the counselor\'s presence as a condition of practice, the counselor\'s own orientation, and practitioner wellness understood as a personal and social matter. The paper concludes the extended series with a brief reflection on what the ten papers, considered together, ask of the ASE-informed school counselor.
A Non-Dual Educator-Counselor Identity
School counselors have long been asked to choose between identities. Some frameworks emphasize the educator, positioning the counselor as a member of the instructional team whose work supports academic achievement. Others emphasize the counselor, positioning the school counselor as a mental health professional who happens to work in a school. Levy and Lemberger-Truelove (2021) argued that this choice is a false one, proposing instead a non-dual educator-counselor identity. In their words, \"the situatedness in schools compels all behaviors to be in service of the educational mission of the school and in support of student needs as learners and social beings. Parallel to the educator identity, the term counselor in school counselor suggests a certain orientation that is concerned with the delivery of services focused on prevention and development that anticipate a medley of wellness and social justice outcomes\" (p. 1).
This identity follows from the same non-dual commitments that ASE theory applies to students. Just as a student\'s learning and well-being are not two separate domains, the counselor\'s educational and counseling functions are not two separate roles. A classroom lesson on co-regulation is education and counseling at once; an individual session with a student who is failing a course is counseling and education at once. The non-dual educator-counselor identity frees the school counselor from defending one role against the other and allows the counselor to understand every activity as serving the student-within-environment.
The Counselor\'s Own Conditions
The ASE framework asks counselors to conceptualize students through culture, constitution, and circumstance. The same framework applies to counselors themselves. A counselor brings a culture (e.g., family and community background, professional training, the culture of the counseling profession), a constitution (e.g., temperament, history, the implicit expectations formed in the counselor\'s own relationships), and a circumstance (e.g., caseload, the day\'s schedule, the conflict that occurred in the hallway an hour ago). Each of these enters the counseling relationship as a condition.
Figure 1 situates the counselor within the ASE triad of counselor, student, and environment.
Figure 1
The Counselor as Condition Within the ASE Triad
{width="6.25in" height="4.46875in"}
Note. The counselor\'s culture, constitution, and circumstance enter practice as conditions. The counselor\'s presence is a condition of the student\'s experience, and the counselor\'s advocacy and consultation are conditions of the environment.
The figure is meant to correct an assumption that is often implicit in counseling training, namely that the counselor\'s task is to minimize their own influence so that the student\'s experience can emerge undisturbed. ASE theory holds that this is neither possible nor desirable. The counselor is always a condition. The question is what kind of condition the counselor will be.
Presence as a Condition
The fifth paper described non-evaluative presence as the counselor\'s orienting posture in ASE practice. Presence is more than a technique; it is a condition the counselor provides, and like all conditions, it can be cultivated or eroded. A counselor who is regulated, curious, and connected provides a condition in which a student\'s regulation, curiosity, and connection are more likely to emerge. A counselor who is depleted, hurried, or reactive provides a different condition, regardless of the techniques the counselor uses.
This is the reason ASE theory treats the 5Cs as counselor dispositions as well as student capacities. The counselor\'s own co-regulation is the condition under which co-regulation with a student becomes possible. Research on mindfulness among helping professionals suggests that practices that cultivate present-moment, non-judgmental attention can support practitioners\' well-being and their capacity for empathic responding (Shapiro et al., 2007). For ASE-informed counselors, such practices are not self-improvement for its own sake; they are the cultivation of a condition that students inherit.
The Counselor\'s Own Orientation
The third paper described orientation as the meaning, interpretation, and direction through which experience is taken up. Counselors, too, orient. A counselor who has learned to read certain behaviors as manipulation, certain families as uninvolved, or certain students as unlikely to succeed brings those readings into every encounter, often without noticing them. These readings function as conditions for students.
Cultural humility, described as an interpersonal stance that is other-oriented and open to the cultural identities and experiences of others, offers a useful complement to ASE theory here (Hook et al., 2013). ASE theory adds that cultural humility is a form of observation turned upon one\'s own orientation. The counselor practices noticing their own readings as readings, holding them as one possibility among others, and remaining curious about what they might be missing. This is the same practice the counselor hopes to cultivate in students, applied to the counselor.
Table 1 offers prompts that counselors can use to observe their own conditions and orientation.
Table 1
Prompts for Observing the Counselor\'s Own Conditions and Orientation
-------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Domain Prompt for observation What it might reveal Culture What did my family, community, and training teach me about what problems mean and how they should be solved? Assumptions about help-seeking, authority, emotion, and family roles that may differ from students\' and families\' Constitution What happens in my body when a student is defiant, tearful, or silent? Where did I learn to respond that way? Implicit responses that shape presence before deliberate thought Circumstance What am I carrying into this session from the rest of my day? Fatigue, time pressure, or unresolved conflict that may narrow attention Orientation What story am I already telling about this student or family? What would I notice if I told a different one? Interpretations that function as conditions for the student -------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Practitioner Wellness as Personal and Social
Discussions of counselor wellness often focus on self-care, which is understood as the counselor\'s individual responsibility to maintain their own well-being. ASE theory accepts the importance of self-care, yet it applies to counselors the same principle it applies to students; it is inappropriate and potentially harmful to suggest that wellness is the sole responsibility of the person most affected. School counselors often work under conditions that make wellness difficult, including high caseloads and assignment to duties unrelated to counseling. Research has linked such conditions to stress and burnout among school counselors, which in turn is associated with fewer direct services to students (Mullen & Gutierrez, 2016).
From an ASE perspective, counselor wellness is therefore a matter of reflexive intervention. The counselor attends to their own regulation, relationships, and orientation, and also advocates for conditions of practice that can sustain them (e.g., reasonable caseloads, protected time for direct services, supervision, collegial support). Supervision and peer consultation are particularly important, as they are forms of co-regulation for counselors. A counselor who has a place to bring difficult cases, and who is met there with curiosity and steadiness, is better able to offer the same to students.
The Counselor as Advocate
The final dimension of the counselor as condition is advocacy. The counselor\'s presence is a condition of the student\'s experience, and the counselor\'s advocacy and consultation are conditions of the environment. ASE theory has always held that school counselors must function as ecological advocates and not only as individual helpers (Lemberger & Hutchison, 2014). The analysis in this paper adds that advocacy is itself shaped by the counselor\'s conditions and orientation. A counselor who is depleted will advocate less, and a counselor who has not observed their own readings of students will advocate for some students more readily than others. Attending to oneself as a condition is, in this sense, part of advocacy.
Conclusion to the Extended Series
This paper has argued that the school counselor is a condition within the student-within-environment, bringing culture, constitution, circumstance, and orientation into every encounter. The non-dual educator-counselor identity, the cultivation of presence, the observation of one\'s own orientation, and attention to practitioner wellness as a personal and social matter are each ways of becoming a condition that supports liberation and thriving.
Considered together, the ten papers in this series describe a theory in which nothing stands outside of the field. The student is a conditioned pattern that takes part in conditioning; so is the school, and so is the counselor. Agency is the meeting of conditions and orientation, at every level, and change occurs when conditions and orientation are together directed toward the emergence of curiosity, connectedness, co-regulation, compassion, and contribution. What ASE theory asks of the school counselor is, finally, to participate in that field with awareness, to help students and schools observe and revise the conditions and orientations they live within, and to attend to themselves as one of the conditions that every student they serve will inherit.
References
Hook, J. N., Davis, D. E., Owen, J., Worthington, E. L., Jr., & Utsey, S. O. (2013). Cultural humility: Measuring openness to culturally diverse clients. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 60(3), 353--366. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0032595
Lemberger, M. E., & Hutchison, B. (2014). Advocating Student-within-Environment: A humanistic approach for therapists to animate social justice in the schools. Journal of Humanistic Psychology, 54(1), 28--44. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022167812469831
Levy, I. P., & Lemberger-Truelove, M. E. (2021). Educator--counselor: A nondual identity for school counselors. Professional School Counseling, 24(1b). https://doi.org/10.1177/2156759X211007630
Mullen, P. R., & Gutierrez, D. (2016). Burnout, stress and direct student services among school counselors. The Professional Counselor, 6(4), 344--359. https://doi.org/10.15241/pm.6.4.344
Shapiro, S. L., Brown, K. W., & Biegel, G. M. (2007). Teaching self-care to caregivers: Effects of mindfulness-based stress reduction on the mental health of therapists in training. Training and Education in Professional Psychology, 1(2), 105--115. https://doi.org/10.1037/1931-3918.1.2.105