← Back to ASE Concepts & Practices Series
Purpose of This Paper
The term sapience has appeared throughout the ASE literature, often briefly and often in parentheses. In the ASE Theory Outline, sapience names the relationship between personal, liberated volition and social justice, described as \"the developmentally feasible and appropriate acumen to operate in one\'s ecology.\" In the introductory chapters to the ASE books, sapience is the outcome toward which curiosity is directed, \"an ever-developing wisdom and capacity for deep understanding necessary to make sense of one\'s experiences within various social, academic, and personal contexts.\" Elsewhere, I have described it more simply as wisdom within context. Across these uses, sapience is closely tied to Freire\'s (1970, 1973) notion of critical consciousness, which ASE theory has adopted and, I contend, extended.
The purpose of this paper is to give sapience a fuller treatment. I describe why ASE theory uses the term, what sapience consists of, how it is positioned within the ASE account of conditions and orientation, how it develops across childhood and adolescence, and how it differs from adjustment on the one hand and from cynicism on the other. The paper closes with implications for practice and for how schools might recognize sapience when it appears.
Why Sapience
The Latin sapere means both to taste and to be wise, and the pairing is instructive. Sapience, in its oldest sense, is a kind of discernment that is close to experience, the capacity to sense what a situation is and what it calls for. This is different from knowledge acquisition, which can be accomplished at a distance from one\'s own life. A student can know a great deal about inequality and still be unable to see how it is operating in her own classroom; another student can know very little in formal terms and still read the situation with remarkable accuracy.
ASE theory has used sapience and critical consciousness nearly interchangeably, and the overlap is substantial. Freire (1970) described critical consciousness as the capacity to perceive social, political, and economic contradictions and to take action against the oppressive elements of reality, and contemporary scholars describe it as including critical reflection, a sense of political efficacy, and critical action (Watts et al., 2011). Sapience includes all of this. ASE theory prefers the broader term for two reasons. First, sapience includes the reading of one\'s own orientation as well as the reading of social conditions, as the wisdom literature emphasizes (described below). Second, sapience carries a deeper register that critical consciousness, as it is commonly operationalized, does not always name, namely the recognition of one\'s continuity with others. These two extensions follow directly from the non-dual commitments of ASE theory.
Wisdom as a Contextual Capacity
Psychological research on wisdom offers useful support for the ASE account. Baltes and Staudinger (2000) described wisdom as expert knowledge about the fundamental pragmatics of life, including an awareness of the contexts of life, the relativity of values, and the management of uncertainty. Sternberg (1998) described wisdom as the application of knowledge toward a common good, balancing one\'s own interests with the interests of others and of the broader context. More recently, Grossmann (2017) argued that wisdom is better understood as a situated process than as a stable trait, showing that the same person reasons more or less wisely depending on the conditions of the situation. Grossmann and colleagues (2020) identified perspectival metacognition, including intellectual humility, recognition of others\' perspectives, and the integration of multiple viewpoints, as a common core across scientific accounts of wisdom.
Two findings from this literature are especially relevant to ASE theory. The first is that people tend to reason more wisely about other people\'s problems than about their own, a pattern called Solomon\'s paradox, and that this asymmetry is reduced when people reflect on their own situations from a distanced perspective (Grossmann & Kross, 2014; Kross & Grossmann, 2012). This is consistent with the ASE emphasis on observation and dialogical self-talk described in Paper 3. The second is that wisdom is contextual. If wise reasoning depends on conditions, then sapience is not only something a student has; it is something that settings make more or less available. This is the sense in which ASE theory speaks of sapience as wisdom within context.
What Sapience Consists Of
ASE theory describes sapience as the integration of four movements, which are distinguishable for the purposes of practice but which occur together in lived experience (see Figure 1).
Figure 1
Sapience as Wisdom Within Context
{width="6.25in" height="5.135416666666667in"}
Note. Sapience integrates the reading of conditions, the reading of one\'s own and others\' orientations, discernment, and action with agency and solidarity. The apparent register concerns the forces that shape experience; the deeper register concerns one\'s continuity with others.
Reading Conditions
The first movement is the reading of the conditions from which experience arises. A sapient student can see that her difficulty in a class is related to her sleep, her history with the subject, the way the class is structured, and the expectations attached to students like her. This is the conceptualization practice described in Paper 2, carried out by the student. At its fullest, it includes the capacity to name social and institutional forces (e.g., racism, poverty, cultural erasure, policies that distribute opportunity unevenly) as governors of one\'s own experience and the experience of others.
Reading Orientation
The second movement is the reading of orientation, one\'s own and others\'. A sapient student can notice that she is reading a situation in a particular way, that the reading fits a familiar story, and that others might read it differently. This movement corresponds to the perspectival metacognition that the wisdom literature describes, and it is the movement most closely tied to observation in ASE theory.
Discerning
The third movement is discernment, which ASE theory has described as a process of expansion and contraction. In expansion, the student widens her view of what produced a situation and what might be possible. In contraction, she tightens toward what is worth accepting, what is worth changing, and what she will commit to. Expansion without contraction becomes drift, and contraction without expansion becomes rigidity. This is the movement in which compassion, understood in ASE theory as acceptance with discernment, does much of its work.
Acting With Agency and Solidarity
The fourth movement is action. Sapience that never reaches action is incomplete, as Freire (1970) insisted when he described praxis as reflection and action directed at the structures to be transformed. In ASE terms, this is contribution, the co-regulated effort to change social systems and the personal commitment to social advocacy. ASE theory specifies that sapient action is undertaken with both agency and solidarity, as the student acts as one participant among others in shared conditions.
Two Registers of Sapience
ASE theory describes sapience as operating at two registers, which parallel the two layers of the theory itself (i.e., an apparent layer of practical correspondence and a deeper layer of non-dual ontology).
At the apparent register, sapience is analytic and critical. It involves the capacity to read social, institutional, and historical forces, to name them, and to act on them. This is the register most visible in classroom discussions, advocacy projects, and student voice initiatives, and it is the register most often measured in research on critical consciousness.
At the deeper register, sapience is relational. It involves a recognition that others are not categorically separate, that their suffering is not foreign, and that one\'s own well-being and the well-being of others are bound up together. This is the point at which, in ASE theory, psychological flourishing and ethical solidarity become inseparable. A student at this register understands that a policy is unfair and also experiences the unfairness to others as a matter that concerns her, because the boundary between herself and them is, in the non-dual sense, functional and not absolute.
The two registers depend on one another. Analysis without the deeper register can become a detached critique in which other people are objects of concern. The deeper register without analysis can become a diffuse sympathy that does not know where to act. Sapience holds both.
Sapience Within the ASE Account of Volition
Earlier papers in this series described volition as the meeting of prior conditions and the orientation of experience, and described freedom as a matter of degree, or the extent to which a person\'s orientation, joined with the orientations of others, takes part in shaping the conditions from which future choices arise. Sapience can now be located precisely. Sapience is an orientation that can read its own conditions and itself. Where an unexamined orientation is carried by its conditions, a sapient orientation can see them, consider them, and take part in rearranging them. Sapience is therefore the means by which freedom, in the ASE sense, increases.
This also explains why the ASE Theory Outline describes sapience as the relationship between personal volition and social justice. Personal volition becomes more liberated as a student can see and influence her conditions; social justice becomes possible as persons can see the conditions that are distributed unevenly and act together to redistribute them. Sapience is the capacity that joins the two.
The 5Cs each contribute to sapience. Curiosity is, in the ASE literature, the pursuit of sapience, as it keeps a reading open to revision. Connectedness supplies the other perspectives that perspectival metacognition requires. Co-regulation keeps the reasoning capacities on which sapience depends available under stress, as threat narrows attention and shifts behavior toward habit. Compassion provides the discernment of expansion and contraction. Contribution is sapience in action.
Developmental Sapience
ASE theory has always described sapience as developmentally appropriate, which means that sapience is not an adult capacity that children lack but a capacity that takes different forms at different ages. Research on critical consciousness similarly describes a developmental progression in which young people\'s capacity to analyze social conditions and to act on them grows across childhood and adolescence, supported by the settings they inhabit (Diemer et al., 2016). Table 1 describes how sapience might appear across developmental levels.
Table 1
Developmental Expressions of Sapience
----------------------------- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Level Reading conditions and orientation Discerning and acting Early childhood (PreK--K) Noticing feelings in the body; noticing that a friend feels differently about the same event; wondering why Choosing among simple options with support; helping a peer; asking an adult for help with something unfair Elementary (Grades 1--5) Naming several reasons for a difficulty, including ones outside oneself; recognizing that people read the same situation differently Making a plan with an adult; proposing a classroom change; standing with a peer who is left out Middle school (Grades 6--8) Examining family, peer, media, and school influences; noticing one\'s own recurring stories; beginning to name systemic forces Weighing what to accept and what to change; joining others to raise a concern; holding a commitment under peer pressure High school (Grades 9--12) Analyzing institutional and historical forces; recognizing assumptions behind one\'s own and others\' beliefs; integrating multiple viewpoints Advocating for policy change with others; making decisions that balance personal goals with obligations to others; sustaining action over time ----------------------------- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The table should be read as describing tendencies and not stages. A first grader can display a moment of remarkable sapience, and an adult can display very little. Because sapience is contextual, the conditions of a classroom matter at least as much as a student\'s age. Research on adolescents suggests that an open classroom climate, in which students are encouraged to discuss issues and voice differing opinions, is associated with greater critical reflection and efficacy (Godfrey & Grayman, 2014). Sapience has a social face as well as a personal one.
What Sapience Is Not
Sapience Is Not Adjustment
A counseling approach whose aim is adjustment helps a student cope with conditions as they are. ASE theory values coping, and it values the immediate relief that counseling can provide. Yet a student who has learned only to endure an unjust condition without seeing it clearly has not developed sapience; she has been trained to accommodate. ASE theory pursues both relief and the growing capacity to perceive, and eventually to reshape, the conditions in question. The counselor\'s attention to the environmental side of every plan models for the student that conditions are the kind of thing that can be named and changed, which is among the first lessons of sapience.
Sapience Is Not Cynicism
The opposite risk is a critical awareness that outruns the capacity to act. A student who learns to see the forces arrayed against her, without also experiencing herself as able to take part in changing them, may become cynical or hopeless. Research on critical consciousness has noted that critical reflection develops alongside a sense of efficacy and opportunities for action (Watts et al., 2011). This is why ASE theory treats contribution as necessary to fully actualize the 5Cs, and why sapience includes action with others and not only analysis.
Sapience Is Not Agreement With the Counselor
Freire (1970) criticized banking education, in which knowledge is deposited by teachers into students. Sapience cannot be deposited. A counselor who leads a student to the counselor\'s own conclusions about a social issue has not cultivated sapience, however accurate the conclusions. Sapience is cultivated dialogically, through questions that help students read their own conditions and orientations and reach their own discernments, which may differ from the counselor\'s.
Sapience in Adults and Institutions
Sapience is not only a student outcome. ASE theory treats the 5Cs as counselor dispositions, and sapience is no different. A sapient counselor reads the conditions of their own practice, observes their own readings of students, discerns what to accept and what to change, and acts with colleagues on the conditions of the school. Institutions can display something like sapience as well. Paper 9 described double-loop learning, in which a school questions the goals and assumptions behind its policies (Argyris & Schön, 1978), and this is the institutional analogue of a student reading her own orientation. A school that can see its own conditions and readings is better positioned to distribute conditions that support sapience in its students.
Implications for Practice and Assessment
Several implications follow for ASE-informed school counselors. First, sapience is cultivated through questions more than through instruction. Questions that ask what conditions made a situation possible, how else it might be read, what is worth accepting and changing, and what one will do and with whom correspond to the four movements of sapience and can be adapted for any age. Second, sapience requires conditions. Classrooms and counseling groups in which differing views are welcomed, in which students\' readings are taken seriously, and in which students have real opportunities to act are conditions under which sapience is more likely to emerge. Third, distanced reflection supports wise reasoning, which gives practical weight to dialogical self-talk and to inviting students to consider how a trusted other might see their situation (Kross & Grossmann, 2012).
Fourth, sapience can be recognized, although it resists simple measurement. Consistent with the dialogical approach to evaluation described in Paper 6, evidence of sapience is best gathered as illustrations of capacity, such as a student\'s account of the conditions behind a decision, a group\'s proposal for change, or a reflection in which a student notices her own reading as a reading. Existing measures of critical consciousness and wise reasoning may also be useful, provided their results are treated as approximations of a contextual capacity and not as fixed scores.
Conclusion
Sapience, in ASE theory, is wisdom within context. It integrates the reading of conditions, the reading of one\'s own and others\' orientations, the discernment of what to accept and what to change, and action undertaken with agency and solidarity. It operates at an apparent register, where it resembles critical consciousness, and at a deeper register, where it becomes a recognition of one\'s continuity with others. Within the ASE account of volition, sapience is an orientation that can see its own conditions and itself, and it is therefore the capacity through which personal freedom and social justice increase together. It develops across childhood and adolescence, and it depends on conditions, which means that schools can make it more or less available to their students. In this sense, the aim of ASE practice includes students who are well and, beyond that, students and schools that grow increasingly wise about the conditions of their own wellness and the wellness of others.
References
Argyris, C., & Schön, D. A. (1978). Organizational learning: A theory of action perspective. Addison-Wesley.
Baltes, P. B., & Staudinger, U. M. (2000). Wisdom: A metaheuristic (pragmatic) to orchestrate mind and virtue toward excellence. American Psychologist, 55(1), 122--136. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.55.1.122
Diemer, M. A., Rapa, L. J., Voight, A. M., & McWhirter, E. H. (2016). Critical consciousness: A developmental approach to addressing marginalization and oppression. Child Development Perspectives, 10(4), 216--221. https://doi.org/10.1111/cdep.12193
Freire, P. (1970). Pedagogy of the oppressed. Continuum.
Freire, P. (1973). Education for critical consciousness. Seabury Press.
Godfrey, E. B., & Grayman, J. K. (2014). Teaching citizens: The role of open classroom climate in fostering critical consciousness among youth. Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 43(11), 1801--1817. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10964-013-0084-5
Grossmann, I. (2017). Wisdom in context. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 12(2), 233--257. https://doi.org/10.1177/1745691616672066
Grossmann, I., & Kross, E. (2014). Exploring Solomon\'s paradox: Self-distancing eliminates the self-other asymmetry in wise reasoning about close relationships in younger and older adults. Psychological Science, 25(8), 1571--1580. https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797614535400
Grossmann, I., Weststrate, N. M., Ardelt, M., Brienza, J. P., Dong, M., Ferrari, M., Fournier, M. A., Hu, C. S., Nusbaum, H. C., & Vervaeke, J. (2020). The science of wisdom in a polarized world: Knowns and unknowns. Psychological Inquiry, 31(2), 103--133. https://doi.org/10.1080/1047840X.2020.1750917
Kross, E., & Grossmann, I. (2012). Boosting wisdom: Distance from the self enhances wise reasoning, attitudes, and behavior. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 141(1), 43--48. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0024158
Sternberg, R. J. (1998). A balance theory of wisdom. Review of General Psychology, 2(4), 347--365. https://doi.org/10.1037/1089-2680.2.4.347
Watts, R. J., Diemer, M. A., & Voight, A. M. (2011). Critical consciousness: Current status and future directions. New Directions for Child and Adolescent Development, 2011(134), 43--57. https://doi.org/10.1002/cd.310