Practice Guide 11 · Companion to Paper 11

Reading the Conditions, Reading Ourselves

Four Questions of Sapience + Perspective Round + Accept-or-Change Sort + Sapience Journal

Matthew E. Lemberger-Truelove — Department of Educational Psychology, Neag School of Education, University of Connecticut

Read companion Paper 11 →

← Back to ASE Concepts & Practices Series

Purpose of This Guide

Paper 11 described sapience as wisdom within context, integrating four movements (i.e., reading conditions, reading orientation, discerning, and acting with agency and solidarity) at an apparent register and a deeper register. This guide describes how sapience shows up in ordinary school life and offers four practices for cultivating it: the Four Questions of Sapience, the Perspective Round, the Accept-or-Change Sort, and the Sapience Journal. Because sapience depends on conditions as much as on the student, the guide also describes how counselors can help classrooms become places where sapience is more likely to emerge.

The Idea in Lived Experience

Sapience rarely looks dramatic. In lived experience, it looks like a fifth grader who, after being left out at recess, says, \"I think they didn\'t pick me because the game was already started, and also because I always want to be the leader.\" It looks like an eighth grader who notices that the dress code is enforced more often on some students than others, and who asks a teacher about it instead of either ignoring it or exploding. It looks like a high school senior who chooses a college close to home, having weighed her own ambitions against her family\'s needs, and who can explain the choice without apology.

Each of these students is reading conditions, reading their own orientation, discerning what to accept and what to change, and acting in some way. None of them has a fully worked-out analysis of social structure. Sapience, at any age, is the capacity to see one\'s situation more clearly than one did before, including oneself in it, and to act on that seeing with others in mind.

Figure 1 restates the four movements of sapience from Paper 11, which organize the practices in this guide.

Figure 1

The Four Movements of Sapience

![The Four Movements of Sapience](media/0cf52622ce67e2f18c84b272c2479408fe65990f.png "The Four Movements of Sapience"){width="6.25in" height="5.135416666666667in"}

Note. Each practice in this guide supports one or more of the four movements. The deeper register, recognizing one\'s continuity with others, is cultivated across all of them.

Practice 1: The Four Questions of Sapience

The Four Questions correspond to the four movements of sapience and can be used in individual counseling, small groups, classroom lessons, and conversations with families. They are simple enough to memorize, which allows students to begin asking them on their own.

> 1\. What made this possible? (reading conditions) What was going on inside me, around me, and in the school or community that helped this happen? > > 2\. How am I reading it, and how might others read it? (reading orientation) What does this mean to me? What story does it fit? How would someone else, perhaps someone very different from me, see it? > > 3\. What is worth accepting, and what is worth changing? (discerning) Of everything that made this possible, what can I make peace with, and what should be different? > > 4\. What will I do, and with whom? (acting with agency and solidarity) What is my part? Who else is affected, and who could act with me?

Table 1 offers developmentally adapted versions of the Four Questions.

Table 1

The Four Questions of Sapience Adapted by Developmental Level

------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Question Early elementary (K--2) Upper elementary (3--5) Middle and high school (6--12) What made this possible? \"What happened right before? How did your body feel?\" \"What were all the reasons this happened, inside you and around you?\" \"What conditions, personal, social, and institutional, made this possible?\" How am I reading it, and how might others read it? \"How did your friend feel about it?\" \"What did it mean to you? Would someone else see it differently?\" \"What story are you telling about this? What would someone with a different background or position say?\" What is worth accepting, and what is worth changing? \"Is this something we can fix, or something we have to be okay with?\" \"Which parts can change, and which parts are just how it is right now?\" \"What will you make peace with, and what should be different? Who decides?\" What will I do, and with whom? \"What could you do? Who could help?\" \"What\'s your plan? Who else needs to be part of it?\" \"What is your part? Who else is affected, and who could act with you?\" ------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Practice 2: The Perspective Round

People reason more wisely about other people\'s problems than about their own, and this asymmetry is reduced when they consider their own situation from a distance (Grossmann & Kross, 2014). The Perspective Round uses this finding in small groups and classrooms.

> 1\. A student (or the group as a whole) describes a situation in a few sentences. > > 2\. Each member, in turn, describes how the situation might look from a particular perspective, either assigned or chosen (e.g., the other student involved, a teacher, a parent, a younger sibling, someone from a different community, the student five years from now). > > 3\. The student who shared the situation listens without responding until the round is complete. > > 4\. The student then says which perspective surprised them most and whether their own reading has shifted.

The Perspective Round cultivates the second movement of sapience directly, and it often touches the deeper register, as students begin to experience others\' perspectives as bearing on their own. Groups should agree in advance that perspectives are offered in good faith and that no one is required to change their view.

Practice 3: The Accept-or-Change Sort

Discernment, the third movement, involves expansion (widening the view of what produced a situation) and contraction (tightening toward what to accept and what to change). The Accept-or-Change Sort makes this movement concrete.

After a student has mapped the conditions of a situation (e.g., using the Kaleidoscope Map from Practice Guide 2), the student sorts each condition into one of three groups: things to accept for now, things to change, and things to take to someone else who has the power to change them. The third group is important. It teaches students that some conditions are neither theirs to accept nor theirs to change alone, and that taking a condition to the appropriate person is itself a form of action.

Table 2

Accept-or-Change Sort Worksheet

--------------- ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ---------------------------------- ------------------------------------ Condition Accept for now (and how I will care for myself while it remains) Change (and what my part is) Take to someone else (and who)

--------------- ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ---------------------------------- ------------------------------------

Practice 4: The Sapience Journal

The Sapience Journal is a brief weekly reflection, appropriate for upper elementary through high school students and for adults. Students choose one situation from the week and respond to the Four Questions in writing or drawing. Over several weeks, the journal makes patterns visible (e.g., recurring stories, conditions that come up repeatedly, kinds of action the student tends to take or avoid). Counselors can review journals with students periodically, asking what the student notices about their own growth. Evidence of sapience, consistent with the dialogical approach to evaluation in ASE theory, is often best found in these reflections.

Arranging Conditions for Sapience

Because sapience is contextual, the settings students inhabit make it more or less available. Research suggests that an open classroom climate, in which students discuss issues and voice differing opinions, is associated with greater critical reflection and efficacy among adolescents (Godfrey & Grayman, 2014). Counselors can work with teachers to arrange such conditions, for example by:

A Lived-Experience Illustration

A group of eighth-grade students, meeting with their counselor in a lunch group, raised the school\'s dress code. Several students, most of them girls and several of them Black, said they were regularly stopped in the hallway for violations that other students were not stopped for. The counselor used the Four Questions. In reading conditions, students named the wording of the dress code, the way it was enforced by a few adults in particular, and, more hesitantly, what one student called \"how some people\'s bodies get noticed more.\" In reading orientation, they noticed that they had been reading the situation as \"they just hate us,\" and in a Perspective Round they considered how the adults who enforced the code might see it, which led one student to say, \"They probably think they\'re being fair. That\'s kind of worse.\"

In the Accept-or-Change Sort, the students placed the existence of a dress code under \"accept for now,\" uneven enforcement under \"take to someone else,\" and their own responses to being stopped (which had sometimes included yelling) under \"change.\" With the counselor\'s support, they gathered a few weeks of their own observations, met with an assistant principal, and proposed that the code be rewritten in neutral language and that enforcement be reviewed. The school formed a committee that included two of the students. In the group\'s final session, one student wrote in her Sapience Journal, \"I\'m still mad about it. But now I know why it happens and what we can do, and I\'m not the only one doing it.\" Her reflection holds analysis, action, and solidarity together. This illustration is fictional.

Practicing in One\'s Own Life

Counselors can practice sapience deliberately, using the Four Questions for their own professional situations (e.g., a conflict with an administrator, a pattern in referrals, a policy that troubles them). The second question, how others might read the situation, is often the most difficult for counselors, who are accustomed to being the person who understands. A Perspective Round among colleagues, in a Peer Co-Regulation Circle (see Practice Guide 10), can be a useful way to practice it. Counselors might also keep their own Sapience Journal for a semester and notice where their readings have shifted.

Adaptations and Cautions

References

Freire, P. (1970). Pedagogy of the oppressed. Continuum.

Godfrey, E. B., & Grayman, J. K. (2014). Teaching citizens: The role of open classroom climate in fostering critical consciousness among youth. Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 43(11), 1801--1817. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10964-013-0084-5

Grossmann, I., & Kross, E. (2014). Exploring Solomon\'s paradox: Self-distancing eliminates the self-other asymmetry in wise reasoning about close relationships in younger and older adults. Psychological Science, 25(8), 1571--1580. https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797614535400

Watts, R. J., Diemer, M. A., & Voight, A. M. (2011). Critical consciousness: Current status and future directions. New Directions for Child and Adolescent Development, 2011(134), 43--57. https://doi.org/10.1002/cd.310