← Back to ASE Concepts & Practices Series
Purpose of This Paper
The first paper in this series argued that Advocating Student-within-Environment (ASE) theory conceives of personal and social agency as a function of two things held together, namely the orientation to experience and the establishment of the complex total of the prior conditions of experience. This paper is concerned with the second of these terms. Specifically, I describe what ASE theory means by prior conditions, why the theory refers to them as governors and not determinants, how the originating Cs (i.e., Culture, Constitution, and Circumstance) organize them, and how school counselors apply this understanding in the practice of conceptualization. The paper concludes with a practice sequence, examples of counseling language, and cautions against two errors that the concept of governors was intended to prevent, fatalism and the discounting of real harm.
From Determinants to Governors
Any theory of human development must account for the forces that precede a person\'s present experience. In public health and in much of the counseling literature, these forces are called determinants, as in the social determinants of mental health (Lenz & Lemberger-Truelove, 2023). The term is helpful insofar as it insists that health and development are shaped by conditions that persons did not choose and cannot simply will away. The term also carries a risk, in that a determinant implies that the mechanism and the outcome are fixed; once the conditions are known, the result can be read off of them.
For this reason, ASE theory adopted the term governors. A governor influences experience without wholly dictating it. The image is partly borrowed from mechanics, where a governor regulates the speed or range of an engine without being the engine itself. Governors establish the range of what is likely and what is available to a person, bringing some experiences and choices near and placing others at a distance. In ASE language, governors are either contributory (i.e., assets) or detracting (i.e., impediments) (Lemberger-Truelove & Bowers Parker, 2024), and the same governor can be contributory in one configuration and detracting in another. Case in point, a family\'s high expectations might be the condition that allows a student to imagine attending college and, in a different week with a different set of pressures, the condition that makes a single failed exam feel catastrophic.
This shift in terminology follows from the non-dual commitments described in the first paper. Because self and environment co-arise, no condition acts upon a student from wholly outside of her, and no condition is simply a property that she possesses. Governors are relational, in that they describe how a feature of body, history, family, culture, or institution enters the field from which experience emerges. Governors are also dynamic, as conditions change and the meaning made of present experience becomes part of the conditions of the next moment.
The Originating Cs
ASE theory organizes governors under three headings that are treated as the most basic prior determinants of experience. These are the first terms in the ASE 3C + 5C = 3C framework, and they are sometimes called the heritable or originating Cs because each is largely given before a person has any say in it. The originating Cs are used primarily in assessment and conceptualization and not as practice targets in themselves.
Culture
Culture includes the individual and collective beliefs, values, customs, and social norms that influence how a person perceives themselves and their place in the world. ASE theory understands culture as cumulative, dynamic, and plural. Every student inhabits several cultures at once (e.g., family culture, ethnic and linguistic heritage, peer culture, faith tradition, neighborhood, school culture), and these cultures intersect more than they stack upon one another. The culture of the school is included here as well. A school\'s routines, its unwritten rules about who belongs in advanced courses, its habits of praise and correction, and its history with particular families are each governors of every student\'s experience in that building.
Constitution
Constitution refers to the aggregate of a person\'s physical and psychological characteristics. In ASE theory, constitution includes predisposition (e.g., temperament, physiology, neurodevelopment, cognitive and physical ability) and also the accumulation of how one has internalized the sum of experience. The latter clause is important, as constitution is not simply nature as opposed to nurture. A nervous system that learned vigilance through years of unpredictability carries that history as constitution, and family dynamics and cultural priorities, once internalized, are part of a person\'s constitution as surely as eye color. The etymology is instructive here; constitution derives from the Latin constitutus, meaning set up or established.
Circumstance
Circumstance includes the immediate, changeable conditions, facts, or events that accompany and condition the commingling of culture and constitution for individuals and groups. A student\'s housing this month, the sleep he had last night, a comment a peer made in the hallway, a new teacher, a death in the family, a schedule change, an unanswered email to a parent, and the start of state testing are each circumstances. Circumstance is where conceptualization becomes most immediately practical, as it contains the governors most open to change in the short term. It also reminds the counselor that much of what looks like a stable characteristic of a student is reflexive to the conditions of the moment.
Distinguishable but Not Separable
The originating Cs sort governors for the purpose of clear thinking, yet none is purely inside or purely outside of the student. Culture is carried in the body as habit and in inner speech as the voices of others; constitution includes internalized culture; and circumstance is experienced through constitution and read through culture. ASE theory therefore treats the three as aspects of one field and not as three separate boxes. A counselor who lists a student\'s governors under each heading has done useful work, although the work is incomplete until the counselor considers how the three are arranged together at present.
The Kaleidoscope as Configuration
ASE theory has long used the image of a kaleidoscope to describe the governors of experience. The colored crystals in a kaleidoscope are real and particular, yet what one sees is the pattern they form, and that pattern shifts with every turn. In a similar way, a student\'s life is continually shaped by shifting interactions among personal, social, academic, and systemic factors.
The metaphor has several practical implications. The same governors can produce very different patterns; two students who share a diagnosis, a neighborhood, and a grade level are not in the same situation, as the arrangement of their conditions differs. Adding or moving one piece also changes the whole, as is the case when a single trusted adult, a new schedule, or the loss of a friend reorganizes a pattern that seemed fixed. Moreover, the pattern is always in motion, and so a conceptualization is a reading of a configuration at a particular turn and not a verdict about who a student is.
The kaleidoscope also illustrates the ASE position on intersectionality. Governors do not combine additively, as though a student\'s experience could be computed by summing the effects of each condition; instead, the meaning and influence of any one governor depends upon the others (Crenshaw, 1989). This is the practical sense of the phrase introduced in the first paper, the complex total of the prior conditions of experience.
Governors Arrive Already Oriented
Prior conditions do not arrive in the present as neutral facts, as they arrive already carrying a direction. A body\'s readiness for threat is meaning that was made in the past and carried forward as physiology. Research on allostasis describes regulation as predictive, in that the brain anticipates the needs of the body on the basis of prior experience and prepares to meet them before they arise (Sterling, 2012). When the prediction has been shaped by chronic threat, the costs accumulate as allostatic load (McEwen, 1998). The prior condition, then, is already an interpretation of what the coming moment will be.
Institutional governors operate in a similar manner. A discipline policy is an interpretation of what behavior means and what school is for, set down in rules; a course placement procedure is a settled judgment about which students are ready for what. ASE theory describes conditions as orientation that has settled and orientation as conditions still in motion. As such, conceptualization is never only a matter of cataloguing what is present. The counselor also considers what each governor is already communicating about the student, and whether that reading is one the student and the school would choose.
No Arrangement of Conditions Is Neutral
The ASE theory of change makes a directional claim about prior conditions, which is that no arrangement of conditions is neutral. Each arrangement brings some possibilities near and pushes others out of reach. The question that ASE theory asks, therefore, is less whether conditions shape choice, since they always do, and more which choices a given arrangement brings within reach and which it forecloses.
ASE theory positions prior conditions, personal and social, toward liberation and thriving. Liberation is the loosening of conditions that narrow the field, or the arrangements of body, history, family, culture, and institution that make a small set of choices feel like the only ones available. Thriving is the cultivation of conditions in which a fuller range of choices becomes livable and can be sustained. Liberation without thriving opens a field that cannot be inhabited, and thriving without liberation is a comfort available only to those whose conditions were never narrowed.
This directional claim has consequences for how ASE practitioners understand resilience. Resilience research has demonstrated that positive adaptation in adversity is common and arises from ordinary protective processes (Masten, 2001), and that it depends heavily upon whether a student\'s ecology makes resources available in culturally meaningful ways (Ungar, 2011). ASE theory honors a student\'s resilience as real capacity, and also reads that resilience as information about the setting. A student who demonstrates remarkable resilience in a setting that wears on her is carrying what the setting ought to be carrying, and an ASE conceptualization attends to both.
The Practice of ASE Conceptualization
The concept of governors becomes practice through conceptualization, or the process by which a counselor (ideally together with the student and the adults around the student) forms a working understanding of the configuration from which present experience is arising. The following sequence is intended as a guide and not a protocol, as its steps overlap in practice.
Step 1: Map Governors at the Personal and Social Levels
The counselor gathers information about culture, constitution, and circumstance at the personal level (i.e., this student) and the social level (i.e., this classroom, family, peer group, and school). Sources of information include conversations with the student, consultation with teachers and family members, school records, and observation. Because ASE is a strength-focused orientation, the counselor attends to contributory governors with the same care as detracting governors (Zyromski et al., 2022).
Step 2: Consider the Configuration
The counselor considers how the governors are presently arranged. Which governors are amplifying one another? Which choices does the present arrangement make most available to the student, and which does it place out of reach? Where does the pattern appear to have narrowed?
Step 3: Consider What Each Governor Communicates
For the most influential governors, the counselor considers what reading of the student or the situation each one carries. A behavior plan that tracks only infractions carries a reading, as does a student\'s certainty that adults will always side with the teacher.
Step 4: Identify What Can Move
Governors differ in how quickly they can change. Circumstance is usually the most movable in the short term. Culture changes more slowly, largely through the intentional development of community, and constitution changes most slowly, largely through what ASE theory calls composition (i.e., the self that persons put together over time from what was set up). The counselor identifies governors at each of these tempos that the student, the adults, and the counselor could realistically influence.
Step 5: Plan Reflexively
Interventions are planned at the personal and social levels simultaneously, so that what is cultivated in the student is matched by conditions in the setting that can hold it (Lemberger & Hutchison, 2014). Paper 6 in this series develops this principle of reflexive intervention in more detail.
Table 1 summarizes how each originating C might be considered at the personal and social levels, along with sample questions for practice.
Table 1
The Originating Cs at the Personal and Social Levels
------------------- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Originating C Personal and social expressions Sample conceptualization questions Culture The student\'s intersecting family, heritage, faith, peer, and community cultures; the school\'s own culture, norms, and history What does this student\'s family hope school will do for her? What does this school assume about families like hers? Where do these readings align, and where do they collide? Constitution Temperament, physiology, ability, and learning history; internalized relationships and priorities; the school\'s staffing, capacity, and accumulated habits What does his body do when he feels cornered, and where did it learn to do that? What has this staff learned to expect of students like him? Circumstance This week\'s sleep, housing, relationships, and events; this semester\'s schedule, testing, staffing changes, and policies What changed recently? What would need to be different on Monday morning for a different choice to be more available? ------------------- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Counseling Language for Conceptualization
Because conceptualization in ASE theory is dialogical, much of it occurs in conversation with students and adults. The language a counselor uses can either fix a governor as a verdict or hold it as a real and changeable influence, as the following examples illustrate.
A counselor might ask a student, \"What usually happens in your body right before you leave class?\" as opposed to \"Why do you keep walking out?\" The first prompt invites the student to observe a constitutional governor, whereas the second asks the student to defend a choice that was, in that moment, the most available one.
With a teacher, a counselor might suggest, \"Let\'s map what\'s going on for him on the days it goes well and the days it doesn\'t,\" as opposed to asking \"What\'s his problem?\" The former invites a reading of configuration, and the latter asks for a single cause.
With a family member, a counselor might say, \"You\'ve told me how much your family values working hard. I\'m wondering how that shows up for her when a test goes badly.\" In this example, the counselor honors a cultural governor as an asset while also inviting curiosity about how it functions in the present configuration.
With a school leadership team, a counselor might ask, \"Which of our routines make it easier for students to come back after a hard morning, and which make it harder?\" This places the school\'s own culture and circumstance inside of the conceptualization.
Case Illustration
Consider a ninth-grade student, here called Amara, whose attendance has declined sharply since October. An initial reading might attribute the absences to a lack of motivation. An ASE conceptualization would map a different configuration. Culturally, Amara\'s family places great value on education and on caring for younger siblings, and she has recently been asked to take her younger brother to elementary school each morning. Constitutionally, she is a strong reader who becomes anxious when she falls behind and who has learned, over several years, to avoid situations in which she might be seen as failing. Circumstantially, the high school\'s first period begins earlier than her brother\'s school day, and the school\'s tardy policy assigns detention after three late arrivals. Three tardies became a detention, the detention became a reason to avoid school entirely on some days, and the missed days caused her to fall further behind, which in turn deepened the avoidance.
No single governor accounts for this pattern; together, they made staying home the most available choice. Several pieces might be moved, including a schedule adjustment or late-arrival agreement for first period, a conversation with the family about the morning responsibilities, a check-in with a trusted teacher on the days she returns, and a review of whether the tardy policy is producing the attendance it was designed to protect. The family\'s commitment to education, which a deficit-oriented reading might have overlooked, becomes the strongest contributory governor in the plan. This case is fictional, although its structure is common in schools.
Two Cautions
Governors Are Experientially Real
ASE is a strength-focused orientation, and it holds that how governors are experienced is dimensional and dynamic. This position ought not to be confused with reframing harm out of existence. Poverty, racism, disability-related exclusion, violence, and neglect are veritable in the lived experience of students and educators. Efforts to ameliorate detracting governors are efforts to change them, and to help students operate upon them in more personally and socially meaningful ways, without asking students to accept conditions that are inadequate or harmful (Lemberger-Truelove et al., 2018).
Governors Are Not Destiny
The opposite error is fatalism, where a thorough account of a student\'s governors becomes a prediction of where the student will end up. The term governor was chosen to resist this. A conceptualization maps the present configuration in order to identify what can move; it is a beginning for action and not a forecast. Historicity in ASE theory, or the recognition that persons and systems carry their histories forward, is paired with the recognition that these histories are still being made (Roche et al., 2020).
Conclusion
Governors of experience are the ASE term for the prior conditions from which present experience emerges. Organized as culture, constitution, and circumstance, governors are at once personal and social, combine as patterns and not as sums, arrive already carrying a reading of the moment, and can be arranged toward or away from liberation and thriving. Conceptualization in ASE theory is the practice of reading that arrangement with students and the adults around them, honoring what is real in it, and identifying what can move. This is one part of the work; the other part, taken up in the next paper, concerns the orientation through which these conditions are taken up.
References
Crenshaw, K. (1989). Demarginalizing the intersection of race and sex: A Black feminist critique of antidiscrimination doctrine, feminist theory and antiracist politics. University of Chicago Legal Forum, 1989(1), 139--167.
Lemberger, M. E., & Hutchison, B. (2014). Advocating Student-within-Environment: A humanistic approach for therapists to animate social justice in the schools. Journal of Humanistic Psychology, 54(1), 28--44. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022167812469831
Lemberger-Truelove, M. E., & Bowers Parker, H. (2024). An evidence-based systems approach to school counseling: Advocating Student-within-Environment. Routledge.
Lemberger-Truelove, M. E., Carbonneau, K. J., Atencio, D. J., Zieher, A. K., & Palacios, A. F. (2018). Self-regulatory growth effects for young children participating in a combined social and emotional learning and mindfulness-based intervention. Journal of Counseling & Development, 96(3), 289--302.
Lenz, A. S., & Lemberger-Truelove, M. E. (2023). The social determinants of mental health and professional counseling: A call to action. Journal of Counseling & Development, 101(4), 375--380. https://doi.org/10.1002/jcad.12489
Masten, A. S. (2001). Ordinary magic: Resilience processes in development. American Psychologist, 56(3), 227--238. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.56.3.227
McEwen, B. S. (1998). Protective and damaging effects of stress mediators. New England Journal of Medicine, 338(3), 171--179. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJM199801153380307
Roche, R., Hutchison, B., & Lemberger-Truelove, M. E. (2020). Historicity in Advocating Student-within-Environment: Being a socially just school counselor. Journal of Humanistic Counseling, 59(3), 173--187. https://doi.org/10.1002/johc.12143
Sterling, P. (2012). Allostasis: A model of predictive regulation. Physiology & Behavior, 106(1), 5--15. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physbeh.2011.06.004
Ungar, M. (2011). The social ecology of resilience: Addressing contextual and cultural ambiguity of a nascent construct. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 81(1), 1--17. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1939-0025.2010.01067.x
Zyromski, B., Wolfe, T. E., Choi, J., Shrewsbury, S., & Hamilton, M. (2022). Applying an Advocating Student-Environment lens to foster protective factors: School counselors\' role in buffering ACEs. Journal of Child and Adolescent Counseling, 8(1), 1--15. https://doi.org/10.1080/23727810.2021.2021052