← Back to ASE Concepts & Practices Series
Purpose of This Guide
Paper 2 described governors of experience, the ASE term for the prior conditions that influence experience without wholly dictating it, organized as culture, constitution, and circumstance. This guide translates that concept into a practice that can be done with students, families, and educators, and that counselors can also use to understand their own working lives. The practice, the Kaleidoscope Map, is a visual way of laying out the governors present in a situation, sorting them as contributory or detracting, and identifying which of them can move.
The Idea in Lived Experience
When something goes wrong, people tend to look for one reason. A student is failing because he is lazy, or because his parents are divorcing, or because the teacher does not like him. Each of these may be part of the picture, and none is the picture. In lived experience, the governors of a difficulty are many, they interact, and they shift with every turn of the day, as the colored crystals in a kaleidoscope shift with every turn of the tube.
Living with this idea changes the questions people ask. \"What\'s wrong with him?\" becomes \"What is gathered around this, and how is it arranged right now?\" \"Whose fault is it?\" becomes \"What here can move?\" These questions are less satisfying than a single answer, although they are far more useful, because they point toward action instead of verdict. They also tend to soften blame, as it becomes apparent that the student, the family, and the school are each carrying part of the pattern.
Figure 1 shows the basic structure of the Kaleidoscope Map. Each circle holds governors from one of the originating Cs, and the overlapping center represents the student-within-environment, where the three meet.
Figure 1
The Kaleidoscope Map
{width="6.25in" height="5.208333333333333in"}
Note. Governors are placed in the circle that best describes them, although many belong in an overlap. The center represents the student-within-environment, where culture, constitution, and circumstance meet.
Making a Kaleidoscope Map
Step 1: Name the Situation
Begin with a specific situation, such as \"Maya has missed eight days of school since October\" or \"Group work in third period keeps falling apart.\" A specific situation keeps the map focused.
Step 2: Gather Governors
With the student (and, where appropriate, family members or teachers), list everything that might be influencing the situation. Encourage breadth. Include things inside the student (e.g., worries, habits, strengths, sleep), things in relationships (e.g., a friendship, a sibling, a teacher), and things in the setting (e.g., the schedule, a policy, the bus route). Write each on a sticky note or in a list.
Step 3: Place Governors on the Map
Place each governor in the circle that fits it best: culture (e.g., family values, peer norms, language, school expectations), constitution (e.g., temperament, learning history, bodily responses, internalized voices), or circumstance (e.g., this month\'s events, the schedule, current policies). When a governor seems to belong in two circles, place it in the overlap. The discovery that many governors belong in overlaps is itself a lesson in non-dualism.
Step 4: Mark Contributory and Detracting Governors
Mark each governor with a plus sign if it currently helps and a minus sign if it currently hinders. Some governors will receive both, which is common and worth discussing (e.g., \"My family expects a lot of me\" may be both).
Step 5: Mark What Can Move
Mark each governor with a letter indicating how quickly it could change: N for now (this week), S for soon (this semester), or L for later (longer term or outside our reach). Circumstance tends to hold the most N governors. Culture and constitution tend to change more slowly, through community and composition.
Step 6: Choose Two Pieces to Move
Choose one governor in the student\'s own reach and one in the environment\'s reach to move first. Choosing both is the practical form of reflexive intervention. Write down who will do what, by when.
Step 7: Turn the Kaleidoscope Again
Revisit the map in two to four weeks. Some governors will have moved, new ones will have appeared, and the pattern will look different. The map is a reading of a particular turn and not a permanent record.
Language for Practice
Table 1
Sample Prompts for the Kaleidoscope Map
------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- Purpose With students With families With educators Gathering governors \"What makes this harder? What makes it a little easier?\" \"What\'s been going on at home that might connect to this?\" \"When does this go better, and when does it go worse?\" Placing in overlaps \"Is that something about you, about your family, or about school? Could it be more than one?\" \"That sounds like something your family values and something that\'s happening this month.\" \"Is that about the student, the class, or the schedule? Maybe all three?\" Marking plus and minus \"Does that help or get in the way right now? Can it do both?\" \"How does that help her? How might it be weighing on her?\" \"What strengths are in this picture that we haven\'t used yet?\" Marking what can move \"Which of these could change this week?\" \"What could be different at home in the next month?\" \"What could we change in the room by Monday?\" ------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Worksheet: Governor Inventory
The worksheet below can accompany the drawn map, particularly when working with older students and adults who prefer a list.
Table 2
Governor Inventory Worksheet
-------------- ----------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------- ---------------------------------- ----------------------- Governor Culture, constitution, circumstance, or overlap Helps (+), hinders (−), or both Can move now, soon, or later Who could move it
-------------- ----------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------- ---------------------------------- -----------------------
A Lived-Experience Illustration
A seventh-grade student, here called Maya, and her mother met with the counselor about Maya\'s absences. Maya\'s first explanation was \"I just don\'t feel like going,\" and her mother\'s was \"She stays up too late on her phone.\" Both were on the map within minutes, and neither was the whole picture. As the map grew, they placed Maya\'s grandmother\'s recent illness in the overlap of culture and circumstance (the family\'s value of caring for elders, and the fact that Maya now spent afternoons helping), placed Maya\'s stomachaches before school in constitution, placed a new seating chart that separated Maya from her only close friend in circumstance, and placed the school\'s practice of announcing missing assignments aloud in the overlap of school culture and circumstance.
Maya\'s mother marked the family\'s commitment to caring for the grandmother as both a plus and a minus, which led to a tender conversation about how proud she was of Maya and how tired Maya had become. They chose two pieces to move. Maya and her mother would agree on a time for the phone to charge in the kitchen, and the counselor would ask the teacher to reconsider the seating chart and to share missing assignments privately. When they met again three weeks later, attendance had improved, the stomachaches were less frequent, and a new governor had appeared on the map, a lunch group that Maya had joined. This illustration is fictional, although its structure is common.
Practicing in One\'s Own Life
Counselors can map their own working lives with the same tool. A counselor who feels persistently behind might place a caseload of 450 students in circumstance, a habit of saying yes to every request in constitution, and a school culture that treats the counselor as available for any duty in culture. Marking what can move often reveals that the counselor has been trying to move only the constitutional governors (e.g., by working harder), while the circumstantial and cultural governors remain untouched. A map of this kind can become the basis for an advocacy conversation with an administrator, framed around conditions and not complaints.
Adaptations and Cautions
- With young children, use three large drawn circles and pictures in place of words, and limit the map to five or six governors.
- In family meetings, invite each member to add governors, and resist the urge to correct anyone\'s placement. Different placements are information about different orientations.
- Be careful with governors that involve harm (e.g., violence at home, discrimination at school). Placing them on a map does not make them movable by the student, and some require reporting or advocacy beyond the scope of the map.
- Avoid letting the map become a list of deficits. If the map has few plus signs, ask directly about strengths, relationships, and times when things went better.
References
Crenshaw, K. (1989). Demarginalizing the intersection of race and sex: A Black feminist critique of antidiscrimination doctrine, feminist theory and antiracist politics. University of Chicago Legal Forum, 1989(1), 139--167.
Lemberger-Truelove, M. E., & Bowers Parker, H. (2024). An evidence-based systems approach to school counseling: Advocating Student-within-Environment. Routledge.
Ungar, M. (2011). The social ecology of resilience: Addressing contextual and cultural ambiguity of a nascent construct. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 81(1), 1--17. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1939-0025.2010.01067.x