ASE Concepts & Practices · Paper 5

Dialogue as the Substance of Change

Expansion, Acceptance of Multiplicity, and Commitment in ASE Practice

Matthew E. Lemberger-Truelove — Department of Educational Psychology, Neag School of Education, University of Connecticut

Read companion Practice Guide 5 →

← Back to ASE Concepts & Practices Series

Purpose of This Paper

The earlier papers in this series described the philosophical grounding of Advocating Student-within-Environment (ASE) theory, the governors of experience, the orientation through which experience is taken up, and the 5Cs toward whose emergence change is directed. This paper describes how change occurs within an ASE counseling relationship. The central claim is that dialogue is the substance of change in ASE practice and not merely its vehicle; that is, change does not happen after the dialogue, but in it. In what follows, I describe the double truth that dialogue holds, the counselor\'s posture of non-evaluative presence, and the movements of expansion, acceptance of multiplicity, and commitment. The paper then offers guidance for individual counseling, small groups, and consultation, along with the ways in which the process most often goes awry.

The Double Truth

ASE theory begins with two truths that it does not collapse into one another. The first is that neither the self nor the environment is a fixed, essential entity; a student\'s current understanding of herself, and her current reading of her world, are contingent constructions that arose from conditions and could arise differently. The second is that every student arrives with a genuine, phenomenologically real sense of being someone in a particular world. This sense is not a cognitive error to be corrected, as it is the ground of agency and the precondition of commitment.

Many helping approaches lean toward one truth at the expense of the other. Some treat a student\'s self-understanding as fact and work within it, which can leave the student confined to the story with which she arrived. Others treat that self-understanding as a distortion to be corrected, which can leave the student without the sense of ownership needed to choose anything at all. ASE theory holds both, in that the self is not fixed and the student\'s experience of selfhood is genuine, and the environment is not essential and the student\'s sense of being embedded in a particular world is real. This irreducible and is not a philosophical compromise; it is the space in which therapeutic dialogue becomes possible.

Dialogue as Substance

In many counseling models, conversation is a delivery mechanism; the counselor assesses, determines what the client needs, and uses conversation to transmit insight or skill. ASE theory locates change elsewhere. Drawing from dialogical philosophy, the theory holds that the self is constituted in encounter and not prior to it. Buber (1970) described the I-Thou relation as one in which persons become actual in meeting one another, and Bakhtin (1984) described consciousness as constitutively dialogical, always answering and anticipating other voices. If the self is formed in dialogue, then a new quality of dialogue is already a new self in formation.

For this reason, ASE theory suggests that change happens in the dialogue. When a counselor brings non-evaluative presence to a student\'s self-construction, honoring its reality while gently revealing its contingency, a space opens in which the student can encounter her own selfhood differently. She meets it neither as a verdict she must accept nor as a fiction she must abandon, but as a living construction that she is always already making and is therefore capable of making otherwise. The counseling relationship is the first and most immediate instance of the expanded self-in-environment toward which the work is oriented.

Non-Evaluative Presence

Because there is no fixed self against which a student\'s current way of being can be measured, evaluation is displaced as the counselor\'s orienting posture. The ASE-informed counselor is neither the expert on who the student really is nor a technician who will correct a deficient self. Instead, the counselor is a dialogical partner whose quality of presence (i.e., curious, connected, non-judgmental) models the very capacities being cultivated.

This posture has deep roots in humanistic counseling. Rogers (1957) identified unconditional positive regard and empathic understanding as conditions under which constructive personality change occurs. ASE theory retains these commitments and adds a non-dual emphasis, in that non-evaluative presence is more than warmth; it is a form of attention that, by suspending judgment, allows the constructed and therefore reconstructible nature of the present self-in-environment to become apparent to the student. Freire (1970) described dialogue in education as requiring humility, faith in people, and hope. A counselor who enters the conversation already certain of what the student should become has left dialogue behind, however kind the intention.

The acme counseling tactic in ASE theory is to empathize in a manner that forges a deep mutual connection while also encouraging the expansion of concepts, interpretations, opportunities, and behaviors. The practice is dialogical in that it delicately threads an appreciation of the truth of a student\'s lived experience while at the same time stimulating diverse and novel possibilities. Connection without expansion leaves the student where she began, and expansion without connection is likely to feel to the student as though she has been told she is wrong.

The Movements of Change

ASE theory describes several movements within the dialogue. These are presented in sequence for the purpose of clarity, although in practice they recur, overlap, and return in a spiral as opposed to a straight line.

Expansion

The first movement is expansion, or the loosening of the apparent solidity of a student\'s current self-construction and of her construction of her relational world. Expansion is not destabilization for its own sake. It reveals what was already true, namely that the self the student has understood herself to be is one possibility among many, and that the environment she has experienced as given is one configuration among others that the same relational field could support.

Expansion often begins with curiosity about exceptions, other voices, and other readings. A counselor might ask, \"When is this not true about you?\" or \"Who in your life sees you differently?\" or \"If your grandmother were here, how would she describe what happened?\" Each prompt invites the student to notice that her present account is an account, and that other accounts are available.

Acceptance of Multiplicity

The second movement is the acceptance of multiplicity, or the willingness to hold several possible selves and several possible worlds without immediately collapsing them into a single story. Research on possible selves suggests that people\'s representations of who they might become, hope to become, or fear becoming influence motivation and behavior (Markus & Nurius, 1986). ASE theory adds that holding these possibilities together, as opposed to rushing to decide among them, is itself a developmental accomplishment.

This movement requires safety. A student under threat will reach for the most familiar story, as familiar stories are predictable. The counselor\'s task is to remain with the student in the discomfort of not yet knowing, and to treat the coexistence of several possibilities as interesting and not alarming. Dialogical self theory describes the self as a society of positions, each with its own voice (Hermans, 2001), and acceptance of multiplicity allows those positions to speak with one another instead of one silencing the rest.

Commitment

The expansion of possibility is not, however, the end of the work. A student adrift in unlimited possibilities without the capacity for commitment is not free, but unmoored. The third movement is therefore intentional commitment, in which the student, grounded in her genuine sense of selfhood and supported by the dialogical relationship, chooses from among the possibilities that expansion has revealed.

This choice is neither arbitrary nor uncaused. It is a new configuration of conditions that the dialogue itself has helped to assemble, guided by the emerging 5Cs and oriented toward greater relational aliveness, contribution, and participation in shaping a more generative environment. It is the phenomenological reality of the student\'s selfhood that makes commitment meaningful. Because she experiences herself as an author of her own life, she can own what she has chosen, inhabit it with conviction, and advocate for the conditions that will sustain it. The non-dual ontology opens the space of possibility, and the phenomenological self steps into that space and commits. In observing that choice and naming what it means, the student adds a new condition to the field from which her next choice will arise.

Enactment Through the 5Cs

Commitment is enacted and sustained through the 5Cs, and each C, when practiced, changes the texture of the interface between self and environment. Because neither self nor environment is ever finally given, enactment is never a final step; each cycle of expansion, acceptance of multiplicity, commitment, and enactment opens new dimensions of the self-in-environment that the student is continuously building. In this way, the ASE theory of change is a dialogical spiral and not a linear progression from problem to solution.

Table 1 summarizes these movements, the counselor\'s primary task within each, and sample counseling language.

Table 1

Movements of Change in ASE Dialogue

---------------------------- ------------------------------------------------------------------------ ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Movement Counselor\'s primary task Sample counseling language Expansion Loosen the solidity of the current account while honoring its reality \"That\'s how it has felt for a long time. I\'m curious whether there have been moments, even small ones, when it was different.\" Acceptance of multiplicity Hold several possibilities without rushing to resolve them \"It sounds like part of you wants to quit the team and part of you would miss it. Let\'s let both of those parts talk for a minute.\" Commitment Support the student in choosing, with authorship, from what has opened \"Of the possibilities we\'ve looked at, which one feels most like yours? What would choosing it ask of you, and of the people around you?\" Enactment Connect the choice to practice and to the conditions that can hold it \"What\'s one way you could practice that this week? Who would you want to know about it, so they can help?\" ---------------------------- ------------------------------------------------------------------------ ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Case Illustration

Consider an eleventh-grade student, here called Daniela, who meets with her school counselor after her parents told her that she must pursue nursing. For two years she has been drawn to graphic design, but she describes herself as \"the responsible one\" who cannot disappoint her family, who moved to this country so that their children would have stable careers. She arrives certain that there are only two options, to obey or to betray.

The counselor begins with connection, reflecting how much her family\'s sacrifices mean to Daniela and how heavy the decision feels. Expansion follows when the counselor asks about times Daniela has been both responsible and creative, and Daniela recalls designing materials for her church\'s food drive, which her mother proudly showed to relatives. The counselor wonders aloud whether \"responsible\" and \"creative\" must be opposites. In the movement toward multiplicity, Daniela considers several possible selves, including a nurse who designs on the side, a designer who works in health communication, and a student who explores both pathways for a year before deciding. None is chosen yet, and the counselor asks what each would mean to Daniela and to her parents.

Commitment comes several sessions later, when Daniela decides to propose to her parents that she pursue a design program with coursework in health communication and to invite them to meet with the counselor to discuss it. The counselor also attends to the environment, helping Daniela gather information about careers that join her interests and preparing for a family conversation that honors her parents\' hopes. When her parents agree to consider the idea, Daniela and the counselor name what occurred as connectedness and contribution, as she found a way to choose that kept her family inside of the choice. This case is fictional, although it illustrates how the movements recur and how dialogue extends beyond the counseling office.

Dialogue at the Social Level

The movements described above are not limited to individual counseling. In small groups, the counselor creates conditions in which students hear one another\'s readings of similar experiences, which is often the most potent form of expansion available to adolescents. In classroom instruction, dialogue can be structured so that several interpretations of a problem are considered before any one is chosen.

In consultation with teachers and administrators, the same movements apply to institutional orientations. A student support team that has settled on a single reading of a student can be invited into expansion (e.g., \"What would we see if we assumed this behavior was protecting something?\"), multiplicity (e.g., \"Let\'s list three different explanations before we choose an intervention\"), and commitment (e.g., \"Which of these readings will we act on for the next three weeks, and how will we know?\"). In this way, the dialogical process that changes a student also changes the conditions she inherits.

When the Process Goes Awry

Expansion Without Commitment

When expansion is pursued without movement toward commitment, students can come to experience every certainty as suspect and every choice as provisional. This might resemble insight while leaving the student without a place to stand. The counselor watches for signs that openness has become drift and helps the student locate the sense of authorship from which choice is possible.

Commitment Without Expansion

When a counselor moves too quickly toward commitment, the student often commits to the most familiar option or to the one that the counselor appears to prefer. The resulting plan may be followed for a time, but it is unlikely to feel like the student\'s own, and outcomes achieved under direction are less likely to be experienced as authored.

Consensus in Place of Co-Operation

ASE theory also cautions that reflexive, co-regulated development can inadvertently transmute into consensus or complicity. A dialogue in which a student learns to accept the expectations of a setting that harms her has not succeeded, however calm it may appear. The aim of ASE dialogue is co-operation, in which the student and the setting both adjust, and not compliance, in which one surrenders to the other.

Conclusion

In ASE practice, dialogue is the substance of change. It holds the double truth that the self is not fixed and that the student\'s experience of selfhood is genuine, and it moves through expansion, acceptance of multiplicity, commitment, and enactment in a spiral that does not finally close. The counselor\'s non-evaluative presence makes this possible by modeling the capacities the work hopes to cultivate. And because dialogue occurs at the personal and social levels, the same process that helps a student choose with authorship can help a school reconsider the readings that shape what its students are able to choose.

References

Bakhtin, M. M. (1984). Problems of Dostoevsky\'s poetics (C. Emerson, Ed. & Trans.). University of Minnesota Press.

Buber, M. (1970). I and thou (W. Kaufmann, Trans.). Scribner.

Freire, P. (1970). Pedagogy of the oppressed. Continuum.

Hermans, H. J. M. (2001). The dialogical self: Toward a theory of personal and cultural positioning. Culture & Psychology, 7(3), 243--281. https://doi.org/10.1177/1354067X0173001

Markus, H., & Nurius, P. (1986). Possible selves. American Psychologist, 41(9), 954--969. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.41.9.954

Rogers, C. R. (1957). The necessary and sufficient conditions of therapeutic personality change. Journal of Consulting Psychology, 21(2), 95--103. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0045357